Punkademics
The basement show in the ivory tower
Edited by Zack Furness
In the thirty years since Dick Hebdige published Subculture: The Meaning of Style, the seemingly antithetical worlds of punk rock and academia have converged in some rather interesting, if not peculiar, ways. A once marginal subculture documented in homemade ‘zines and three chord songs has become fodder for dozens of scholarly articles, books, PhD dissertations, and conversations amongst well-mannered conference panelists. At the same time, the academic ranks have been increasingly infiltrated by professors and graduate students whose educations began not in the classroom, but in the lyric sheets of 7” records and the cramped confines of all-ages shows.
Punkademics explores these varied intersections by giving voice to some of the people who arguably best understand the odd bedfellows of punk and academia. In addition to being one of the first edited collections of scholarly work on punk, it is a timely book that features original essays, interviews, and select reprints from notable writers, musicians, visual artists, and emerging talents who actively cut & paste the boundaries between punk culture, politics, and higher education.
“The worlds of punk and academia are deliberately dichotomous; the ‘cred’ of the former become ‘certified credentials’ when you enter the latter. This important exploration of the space between the two is weird, uncomfortable, and fraught with mistakes. And we don’t give a fuck if you don’t like it.”
~ Anne Elizabeth Moore, author of Unmarketable: Brandalism, Copyfighting, Mocketing and the Erosion of Integrity and former editor, Punk Planet
“Zack Furness and his nerdy bunch impressively reveal how the alternative tentacles of youthful rebellion are infiltrating and disrupting the predictable routines of the academy.”
— Craig O’Hara, author of The Philosophy of Punk: More than Noise
vl Ici tes 1 ih
aX: TSN 9374-1- 5702?- cre 5 * Lat wil 90000 ES es
baie
Pa Ny a oe il oie
Minor Compositions Open Access Statement — Please Read
This book is open access. This work is not simply an electronic book; it is the open access version of a work that exists in a number of forms, the traditional printed form being one of them.
All Minor Compositions publications are placed for free, in their entirety, on the web. This is because the free and autonomous sharing of knowledges and experiences is important, especially at a time when the restructuring and increased centralization of book distribution makes it difficult (and expensive) to distribute radical texts effectively. The free posting of these texts does not mean that the necessary energy and labor to produce them is no longer there. One can think of buying physical copies not as the purchase of commodities, but as a form of support or solidarity for an approach to knowledge production and engaged research (particularly when purchasing directly from
the publisher).
The open access nature of this publication means that you can:
* read and store this document free of charge
* distribute it for personal use free of charge
* print sections of the work for personal use
* read or perform parts of the work in a context where no financial transactions take place
However, it is against the purposes of Minor Compositions open access approach to: * gain financially from the work
* sell the work or seek monies in relation to the distribution of the work
* use the work in any commercial activity of any kind
* profit a third party indirectly via use or distribution of the work
* distribute in or through a commercial body (with the exception of academic usage within
educational institutions)
The intent of Minor Compositions as a project is that any surpluses generated from the use of collectively produced literature are intended to return to further the development and production of further publications and writing: that which comes from the commons will be used to keep cultivating those commons. Omnia sunt communia!
Support Minor Compositions / Purchasing Books
The PDF you are reading is an electronic version of a physical book that can be purchased through booksellers (including online stores), through the normal book supply channels, or Minor Compositions directly. Please support this open access publication by requesting that your university or local library purchase a physical printed copy of this book, or by purchasing a copy yourself.
Tf you have any questions please contact the publisher: minorcompositions@gmail.com.
Punkademics
e Basement Show in the Ivory Tower
Edited by Zack Furness Minor Compositions 2012
Punkademics Edited by Zack Furness ISBN 978-1-57027-229-5
http://punkademics.com
Interior design by Margaret Killjoy Cover design by Haduhi Szukis Cover images by Rubén Ortiz-Torres & Haduhi Szukis
Released by Minor Compositions Wivenhoe / Brooklyn / Port Watson Minor Compositions is a series of interventions & provocations drawing from autonomous politics, avant-garde aesthetics, and the revolutions of everyday life.
Minor Compositions is an imprint of Autonomedia www.minorcompositions.info | minorcompositions@gmail.com
Distributed by Autonomedia PO Box 568 Williamsburgh Station Brooklyn, NY 11211
www.autonomedia.org info@autonomedia.org
CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION: ATTEMPTED EDUCATION
AND RIGHTEOUS ACCUSATIONS..............000005 5 ‘CAUSE | WANNA BE... PHD?................ 25 TURNING POINT... 0.0.0.0. 00.00 ccc cece eee ene ee eens 27 PUNK ETHICS AND THE MEGA-UNIVERSITY .............. 37 MILO WENT TO COLLEGE............. 000.0 cece eee 49 ON BECOMING A PUNK ROCK SOCIOLOGIST............. 57 FINDING BALANCE IN THE ACADEMY ................... 65 PUNK ROCK DOCS........... 0.0.00 cece eee eee eee 67 PUNK THEORY MIX TAPE, SIDE A........... 89 MAXIMUMSOCIALSCIENCE ............. 00.000 cece eee 91 BUILDING RECORDING STUDIOS WHILST BRADFORD BURNED:..................0.. 105 GROWING UP CLICHED............ 00.0000 cece eee 125 PUNK PEDAGOGY:......0..0 000000 cece eee ee eee 131 HER LIFE WAS SAVED BY ROCK AND ROLL:............. 143 PUNK THEORY MIX TAPE, SIDEB........... 155 LAS ‘WHITE MINORITY: ........0... 00000 cee eee eee 157 THE INTERSECTIONS OF PUNK AND QUEER IN THE 1970S.................00005- 179 MEXIPUNX ss, Si Sacrctetinnite fede usin mn bite aasele 187 PUNK PLACES:........0 0.00000 ccc cece eee eee eens 203 AFTERWORD:tic-) cag eee ee a ae ees 217
AUTHOR BIOS fie ces jade cede eee wae eee eee ol 225
ZACK FURNESS
ATTEMPTED EDUCATION AND RIGHTEOUS ACCUSATIONS:
AN INTRODUCTION TO PUNKADEMICS
THE POSITION BEING TAKEN IS NOT TO BE MISTAKEN FOR ATTEMPTED EDUCATION OR RIGHTEOUS ACCUSATION.
-OPERATION IVY, “ROOM WITHOUT A WINDOW”
1 THINK THE moment at which I realized I was actually turning into a col- lege professor was not on the first day I taught a class in 1999, but when I was listening to an old Operation Ivy tape about a year later and found my- self wanting to sit the band’s singer, Jesse Michaels, down to have a frank discussion. Specifically, I wanted to ask him why, in a song written to both illuminate the politics of ideology (“walls made of opinions through which we speak and never listen”) and express the need for open-mindedness and self-reflexivity, would he choose to intentionally denounce the educational function of his lyrics from the outset? Not being a complete idiot nor un- familiar with the band, I obviously realized that the song “Room Without a Window” (quoted above) was penned by Michaels when he was in his late teens, which is around the time when years of schooling and top-down authority have unfortunately succeeded at the task of turning education — or at least the compulsory, state-sanctioned version — into something
6 PUNKADEMICS
from which young people want to run; I imagine all the more so for the sizeable number of kids in the late ‘80s East Bay (California) punk scene whose parents, like Michaels's dad, were college professors. But whether the lyric intentionally gestures in this direction or is self-consciously ironic is hardly the issue. Indeed, even if the first line just sounded cool when he wrote it, the point here is that I wasn’t singing along, tapping out the beat (as ex-drummers are annoyingly prone to do), or even just engaging in the kind of run-of-the-mill lyrical analysis that has been the bread and butter for both punk fanzine writers and music journalists for over three decades. Rather, it’s that I was busy concocting some bizarre scenario in my head that, if allowed to play out in real life, would have undoubtedly translated into the world’s most boring and pedantic conversation with one of my punk heroes.
As if it didn’t feel weird enough to catch myself pursuing this rather strange line of hypothetical inquiry at the breakfast table one morning, the sensation was heightened when I also realized, perhaps for the first time, that my own internal monologue was now being structured around concepts and jargon from my graduate seminars. Since when, I thought to myself, did I start to throw around — let alone think with — phrases like “illuminate the politics of ideology”? Was I becoming the kind of person who ends up nonchalantly remarking upon the “narrative tensions” in a Jawbreaker song? Or using the word oeuvre to describe Bad Brains’s dis- cography? Was I heading down a path where I would eventually not even be able to go for a bike ride without theorizing it?! Just then, as ifthe uni- verse wanted to accent the point in as cartoonish a manner as possible, I narrowly avoided stumbling over my cat while rising from the table, and I managed to spill half a mug of coffee onto the stack of student papers I had been grading. Muttering to one’s self? Check. Coffee stained papers? Check. Analyzing one’s music collection through the lenses of critical pedagogy and rhetorical theory? Check. Shabby outfit? Certainly. Di- sheveled hair and off kilter eyeglasses? Indeed. Exhibiting behaviors that one might objectively identify as ‘wacky’ or ‘nutty’? Check.
It was official. All I needed now, I thought to myself, was the kind of jacket where the patches are sewn nicely onto the elbows instead of silk screened and stitched across the back with dental floss.
ELBOW PATCHES AND BACK PATCHES
Twelve years later I still don’t have one of those professorial tweed jackets, though I did manage to attain the job, the eccentricities, and the shock of salt-and-pepper hair that would compliment one quite nicely.
ATTEMPTED EDUCATION AND RIGHTEOUS ACCUSATIONS 7
And despite my initial anxieties over the prospects of compromising my then-entrenched punk ethics by turning into a stuffy academic, I actually ended up spending more time playing in bands and participating in vari- ous aspects of DIY punk culture as a graduate student and eventual pro- fessor than I did when I was younger. While far from seamless, I’ve often seen the relationship between these two ‘worlds’ as dialectical, though at first this mainly consisted of scrutinizing every new set of readings and concepts I learned in school through my own increasingly politicized worldview: a punk subjectivity that I fancied as something of a “bullshit detector.” But fairly quickly, though, my immersion in critical theory, cultural studies, feminism and political theory started to help me hold up a mirror to sub-/countercultural politics and to generally unpack some of the bullshit that is often embedded within our own bullshit detectors, as it were. Part of what facilitated this process, aside from personal experi- ence and the guidance of some older friends, was getting exposed to the broader gamut of political punk and hardcore and to the range of writ- ers, teachers, artists and activists who, in publications like Bad Subjects, Punk Planet, Maximumrocknroll (MRR), Clamor and Stay Free!, not only connected many of the issues and concerns I'd previously encountered within different spheres, they also complicated and problematized (in the good way) a lot of my taken for granted assumptions about punk and the proliferation of ideas in general. It was through these channels — DIY punk and DIY publishing — as opposed to the classroom, that the relationships between politics, popular culture, education, and everyday life first started to make sense to me.
As crucial as the composition of these ingredients was to my own development and positionality as a teacher, writer and ‘musician’ (a term I use very loosely), I am hardly the first person to test out the recipe and I'm certainly not one of the best cooks. Indeed, my real interest in punk/ academic border transgressions was not borne of my own maneuverings, but from learning about and meeting punk musicians who had dual ca- reers as professional nerds (I use the term lovingly; it is my job descrip- tion after all) and reading sophisticated work from writers who seemed as equally sure footed in zine columns and basement shows as they did in a theory heavy journal publications, political organizing committees, or in front of podiums lecturing to graduate students at prestigious research universities. In addition to being generally interested in what other peo- ple have done (or aspired to do) with the kinds of energies, knowledges and tensions generated through their involvement with, or their reflec- tions upon, both punk music and culture, I had a personal interest in wanting to meet more of these folks and to pick their brain about their
8 PUNKADEMICS
paths toward careers as nerdy rockers or punk professors (given that ei- ther one sounded ideal to me). I was also intensely curious about the ways in which people reconciled their interests and understood the dy- namics between two very different ‘scenes.’ I wanted to hear what other people had to say about scholarship on punk, or their relationships to band mates and fans (if applicable). And broadly speaking, I wanted to know what kind of sense people made of their punk/academic situation; whether it was something they analyzed, disparaged, incorporated into their work, trumpeted, or simply took in stride. What kind of stories did they have? What kinds of insights about punk and teaching have they drawn from their experiences or analyses?
Unlike the prospects of time traveling to an Operation Ivy show in 1990, the possibilities for actually starting some conversations around these topics was quite real, and a few years ago I started the process with the aim of garnering essays for the book you are now reading. I asked people to contribute work that was either about punk specifically, or the intersections between punk and higher education, whether in the form of biographical pieces or chapters devoted to teaching and pedagogy. To keep things simple, I took the approach that punks of yore utilized when contacting bands they liked: sending letters. My interest was less in nos- talgia (they were e-mails, after all) than in making contact with people whose work I admired and otherwise beginning what would become a long experiment. That is to say, part of my reason for doing the book was because, first and foremost, I wanted to see if it was possible. While I had long been attuned to the fact that there were some professors and many more graduate students who, like me (circa 2005, when I hatched the idea for this book), simultaneously played in bands while they taught classes and worked on their degrees, I often wondered about whether there are a lot of “us” out there. By “us” I mean punkademics, or the pro- fessors, graduate students, and other PhDs who, in some meaningful or substantive way, either once straddled or continue to bridge the worlds of punk and academia through their own personal experiences, their schol- arship, or some combination thereof.
Part of the experiment was also to see if I could do the book without resorting to the preferred method that academics use to solicit contribu- tions for an edited volume. This typically entails circulating an official “Call for Papers’ online, waiting for abstracts to trickle in, then sending out acceptance and rejection notices, and eventually waiting for the first drafts of essays to be submitted. Given the formalities and relative ste- tility of the whole process, it seemed much more organic (for lack of a less abused, greenwashed term) to try and find prospective contributors
ATTEMPTED EDUCATION AND RIGHTEOUS ACCUSATIONS 9
by simply asking my initial list of contacts for the names of friends, or other suggestions for people to look up. In addition to my desire to keep things on a personal level, it also dawned on me quite early in planning the book that there was simply no other way to do it. That is to say, I realized that any official announcement aimed at soliciting contributors would not only have to include the obligatory list of suggested topics or questions for authors to address (which I had ready to go), it would also have to delineate some sort of criteria for the authors themselves, given the core premise of the book. Well, establishing that someone is a profes- sor or PhD student is fairly straightforward, but what exactly was I going to do, ask people to send me an abstract and a punk résum@ Aside from all the vexing questions it immediately raises about what punk is, what it means to de punk, what the objective qualities of ‘punk-ness’ might be, and so on, I couldn't imagine anything more obnoxious than the idea of asking people, even tacitly, to basically ‘prove’ that they were or are punks — let alone the awkwardness of someone having to actually write it up, or me having to read it. What the hell would that look like anyway? And more to the logistical point, how does one articulate that in a call for papers? Something like:
Along with your abstract and an updated copy of your CV,
please provide evidence of past or present punk affiliations.
Acceptable forms of documentation may include, but are
not limited to, any one or more of the following:
¢ LP or 7-inch with legible recording credits on the insert (colored vinyl is a plus).
* Copies of your print fanzine.
¢ Notarized letter from a known punk who can vouch for your scene ‘cred.’
¢ Receipts for at least two previous years of annual sub- scriptions to Maximumrockandroll, Punk Planet, Heartat- taCk or Profane Existence (PDF or low-res JPG files).
¢ Photos of you doing punk things (i.e. dumpstering baked goods, swimming drunk in an urban river) or simply be- ing punk (ite. sporting a sleeveless Nausea t-shirt, a nasty dreadhawk, and a dog on a rope).’
While in hindsight this approach may have actually yielded some fairly spectacular results, I was fortunately able to avoid such potentially unforgivable transgressions with help from this book’s authors and an ad hoc network of punkademics that, at times, I seemed to connect or
10 PUNKADEMICS
expand through the very process of seeking it out. While I have no em- pirical data regarding the actual size and scope of this disparate popula- tion, I can confidently speak to one of my initial curiosities underlying this project by noting that there are, in fact, many punkademics out there: far more than I could ever hope to accommodate in a single book, even if given the opportunity to do so.
So what is one to make of this collection, its shamelessly punning section headings, and the punk-centric assortment of essays, people, and ideas in the pages that follow? Simply put, why Punkademics? Well, de- spite the admittedly experimental nature of this collection, there are in fact a number of carefully formulated reasons as to why this collection was assembled and, I can only hope, a few contributions it might make to the ways in which we understand the cultural, political and aesthetic dimensions of both punk music and culture, academia, and the appar- ently fertile ground in between. I want to walk through some of them here briefly, as a way to provide additional context for this project and to introduce some of the specific themes with which the book is engaged.
PUNK DISCOURSES
Punk is neither a homogenous ‘thing’ nor is it reducible to a specific time, location, sound or a select number of vinyl records and live per- formances. Its various meanings, as any self-respecting punk knows all too well, are subject to wild fluctuation and widespread debate.* One might say that it’s because punk shapes — and is also shaped by — specific kinds of question askers, music makers, thought provokers, organizers, shit talkers, writers, artists, and teachers. At their best, the combinations of people, places, cultural practices, social relationships, art and ideas that co-constitute punk are rife with possibilities: creating new kinds of music or reveling in the ecstatic moments at the best shows; forg- ing bonds of group solidarity and personal identity; carving out non- commercial spaces for free expression and the staking out of positions; and pushing people toward a participatory, ‘bottom up’ view of culture. Through the often conflicting accounts and histories of punk, one can identify the ebb and flow of countless scenes, interwoven subcultures, and a broader ‘Do it Yourself? (DIY) counterculture in which people put ethical and political ideas into practice by using music and other modes of cultural production/expression to highlight both the frustrations and banalities of everyday life, as well as the ideas and institutions that need to be battled if there is any hope of living in a less oppressive world. And crucially, people have a lot of fun doing it. Those lucky enough to have
ATTEMPTED EDUCATION AND RIGHTEOUS ACCUSATIONS "1
experienced some of what I’ve just sketched out know what it feels like to sense that punk really can create something new in the shell of the old, to poach a phrase from the Wobblies.
At its worst, punk can be and has been a fashion show, a cultural ghetto, a minor league circuit for corporate entertainers, a merchan- dise peddling aggregate of aspiring capitalist hustlers, and a constella- tion of practices that perpetuate varying degrees of machismo, sexism, homophobia, white privilege, classism, hyper-individualism, anti-intel- lectualism, passive conformity, and at times, both conservative religious dogma and racist nationalism. And like the worst trends to emerge under the banner of cultural studies — the academic field in which I work — punk’s incarnates have similarly been known to promote sloppy politics while championing ‘resistance’ in all of its self-styled affairs, regardless of whether such gestures (or fanciful arrangements of clothing, tattoos or words) bear a resemblance to anything like substantive political ac- tion, meaningful community engagement, or tangible social change. In this guise, ‘resistance’, ‘rebellion’, and of course, ‘revolution’, become just another set of buzzwords chirped in slogans, animated in bad songs and contrived writing, and emblazoned on t-shirts without a hint of Billy Brage’s sharp wit: “So join the struggle while you may, the revolution is just a t-shirt away.”
The various prospects and pitfalls associated with punk (I include hardcore in this designation throughout unless noted otherwise) are con- stant reminders that the stories we tell about it are always being folded into converging and often competing discourses about what punk really means, what it does or doesn’t do, and why it is or isn’t culturally signifi- cant, politically relevant, and so on. As both an academic and someone who spent roughly thirteen years drifting in and out of the punk scene (admittedly more ‘out’ in recent years), I’m invested in both the kinds of stories that get told about punk as well as the manner in they are put to work, as it were. Therefore, I think it is important to note from the outset that my interest in assembling Punkademics is neither to tell the grand story of punk (an impossibly arrogant and pointless task) nor to produce the scholarly cipher through which all of punk’s secret mean- ings can be decrypted. Academics should not be seen as the authoritative voices capable of explaining punk to the masses, and I have no interest in presenting them as such. In fact, I have always been rather conflicted about how punk music and DIY punk culture get taken up by academics in the first place.
As a teacher, I tend to see punk — like all other cultural phenomena — as a messy but nonetheless fascinating cluster of things that can be
12 PUNKADEMICS
analyzed, dissected and debated. Depending on the specific course, I’ve incorporated aspects of punk in my lesson plans to talk about everything from the underground press and the political economy of the media in- dustry, to the role that punk music — like hip hop — plays in cultivating meaningful narratives about “the city” and the importance of space and place in everyday life.° And quite frequently, punk comes in handy when I need to give concrete examples to illustrate or clarify what certain social and cultural theorists mean when they throw around phrases like cultural production, articulation, hegemony, resistance, commodification, cooptation, and of course, subculture. In addition to being pedagogically useful, I also get a certain degree of satisfaction in knowing that members of the bands I discuss in class would be alternatively delighted or mortified by the idea.
However, my level of comfort with the melding of punk and aca- demia decreases quite rapidly when punk becomes an object of study unto itself. As Roger Sabin notes in his introduction to Punk Rock, So What?, one of the main problems with scholarship on punk is the over- reliance on unquestioned assumptions about punk itself and, overall, the “narrowness of the frame of reference.” Along with what he describes as the “pressures to romanticize,” Sabin suggests that the impulses and trends in punk scholarship foster the development of certain kind of “orthodoxy” that structures what it is possible to say, or most likely not say, about punk’s history, its conjunctures with other ideas and artis- tic practices, and, I would add, its current formations, and its possible future(s).” Like many of the LP records that fit squarely and safely within the parameters of a punk’s splintered subgenres, a number of the books and essays that fall under the umbrella of this ‘orthodoxy’ have their distinct merits.’ Nevertheless, his point about the constrictive qualities of scholarship on punk is well taken and, broadly speaking, rather un- derstated.? Because while there are plenty of exceptions (including excel- lent work published by this book’s contributors), a significant amount of academic writing, conference presentations and the like are authored by people who — despite being fans of punk music and passionate about the topic — seem to have limited knowledge of punk music and DIY culture, and a level of engagement with punk scenes that is more akin to casual tourism than active participation. Nevertheless, this doesn’t stop people from feeling entitled to make assumptions, lodge critiques, and draw conclusions based on what, more or less, amounts to an analysis of punk ‘texts.’ To be sure, there are a variety of things that broadcast this kind of work. Barring some notable exemptions, the telltale signs may include, but are certainly not limited to, any or all of the following features:
ATTEMPTED EDUCATION AND RIGHTEOUS ACCUSATIONS 13
No interviews conducted with actual punks.
No ethnographic research done at any of the places where punks live, make music, work, play and see shows, hang out, ride bikes, get drunk, guzzle coffee, play kickball, raise a ruckus, stage pro- tests, volunteer, cook food, and so on.
Little attention paid to punk scenes that fall outside the osten- sibly holy quadrangle of New York — London — Los Angeles — Washington DC, despite the fact that in recent decades DIY punk and hardcore scenes have thrived in smaller, so-called second — or third-tier cities like Berkeley (CA), Asheville (NC), Portland (OR), Minneapolis (MN), Olympia (WA), Pittsburgh (PA), Bloomington (IN), Louisville (KY), Gainesville (FLA) and Richmond (VA), and this is just to name a few places in the US alone.'°
Relatively little engagement with the vast amount of literature written by and about punks, whether in the form of zines, pub- lished essays, books, magazine columns, LP liner notes, blogs and so on.
The use of definite articles in places where they don’t belong, as in “the Dillinger Four” instead of Dillinger Four, or “the Green Day band.” Trivial? Absolutely. But it is the kind of mistake that a punk is not likely to make and thus suggests the likelihood of other mistakes, or a general lack of knowledge about the subject matter.'' And moreover, it conveys an awkwardness on par with John McCain’s reference to using “a Google,” whilst ironically at- tempting to demonstrate his Internet savvy to US voters prior to the 2008 presidential election.
An almost obsessive fascination with the Sex Pistols and Malcolm McLaren.”
An obsessive fascination with the Sex Pistols and Malcolm McLaren."
Any sustained, serious theoretical analysis of “moshing” or “slam dancing.”
Less space devoted to discussing what punks do, what they think, and why it matters, than the amount of space reserved for debating whether to call them a “subculture,” a “post-subcul- ture,” a “youth culture,” a “postmodern tribe,” or a “neo-tribe.” There are, in fact, many terms that are actively contested and discussed by punks: debates over what counts as ‘punk’, or what it means to de ‘punk’, are classic (if not exhausting) examples. But the merits of sociological/cultural studies nomenclature are
14 PUNKADEMICS
not part of the equation. To wit, the following exchange will never take place:
“Hey Zack, what are you doing this weekend?” “Well, ’m busy on Friday, but on Saturday
night I’m going to participate in a vigorous rock
and roll performance with members of my cultural
neo-tribe.”
10. The conflation of punk with 100% pure authentic resistance to the culture industry/mainstream/system, or conversely, as 100% pure inauthentic commodified dissent in service of the culture industry/mainstream/system.
I recognize, of course, that this (partly tongue-in-cheek) assessment may sound like the expression of someone who is too emotionally in- vested in his subject matter, or perhaps too ensnarled in punks’ own pre- occupations with boundary-making and authenticity (“no outsider could ever know what it’s really like,” etc.) to make clear-headed judgments about scholarship, let alone the researchers responsible for producing it. It’s certainly possible.
My position, however, is not based on some naive desire to preserve the sacredness of punk (Hot Topic put the final, pyramid-studded nail in that coffin years ago), nor do I think that people who are totally im- mersed in their activities or communities are necessarily in the best posi- tion to speak thoughtfully about their endeavors, or to critically reflect on the social or political significance of them; sometimes the exact op- posite is true. Rather, my perspective is based upon what I see as a rela- tively uncontroversial point: whether due to shoddy research, distance from the punk scene, or harmless excitement for a topic tackled earnestly though wrong-headedly, the bottom line is that most academics simply miss the mark when it comes to punk music and culture. It would seem that I am good company on this point, even amongst fellow academ- ics. John Charles Goshert, for example, argues that academic studies “tend toward the uninformed, if not careless, homogenizing of styles, personalities, and locales under the name ‘punk.””'® David Muggleton expresses similar anxieties over the academicization of punk when, in the introduction to his own book, he describes his first encounter with Dick Hebdige’s Subculture: The Meaning of Style: “I fought my way through... and was left feeling that it had absolutely nothing to say about my life as Thad once experienced it... The ‘probleny lay not in myself and my failure
ATTEMPTED EDUCATION AND RIGHTEOUS ACCUSATIONS 15
to recognize what had ostensibly been the reality of my situation, but in the way the book appropriated its subject matter.”!”
Here’s the rub, though: appropriation is always a matter of per- spective. As a case in point, when Muggleton organized the No Future? Punk 2001 conference at the University of Wolverhampton ten years ago, it brought a wide range of academics and cultural critics together with some high profile punk speakers who weren't shy about airing their grievances when interviewed by the press. The ever-cantankerous writer/ artist/author, Stewart Home, stated, “I think punk is hyped up as an ongoing cultural force by people who are nostalgic for their youth.”"® Jordan (aka. Pamela Rooke), who was the former assistant at Vivienne Westwood’s famed London SEX shop and one of the people who pio- neered. punk aesthetics/style, remarked that “the academic world reads more into punk than there probably was.”'? And most pointedly, Penny Rimbaud, a poet and the drummer for the now legendary anarcho-punk band, Crass, exclaimed: “It irritated me beyond belief...academics sit- ting round talking about something so anti-academic. It’s as absurd as the Hayward Gallery putting on a show of dada art.””°
Part of the reason I juxtapose these quotes and also call attention to the No Future conference is because at the same time I think academics should take criticism of their work seriously — particularly when its gen- erated by human beings who unwittingly serve as their ‘objects’ of study — the notion of drawing a proverbial line in the sand between ‘the punx’ and ‘the ivory tower’ based on whether one’s work is properly “academic” is somewhat amusing, especially if one has ever been privy to a conversa- tion between collectors of obscure punk and hardcore records (musicol- ogy by other means, if there ever was such a thing), and even more so if one considers either Home’s specific background as a historian of highly theoretical, avant-garde art movements or Rimbaud’s own proclamation — leaving aside the militant seriousness with which Crass approached both politics as well as its aesthetic presentation of politics — that even his notion of fun has “always been more cerebral and intellectual.”?! There are, of course, completely legitimate reasons why punks should be radi- cally skeptical about the ways their music, ideas and cultural practices are documented by representatives of institutions (colleges & universities) that are, by design, the antithesis of DIY. But in general, staking one’s claim on the grounds that punk is inherently “anti-academic” isn’t to state an uncontested fact; it is rhetorical move that, in part, allows punks to avoid dealing with thorny questions or critiques raised by outsiders (some of whom, it is true, may be utterly clueless), just as it simultane- ously reinforces academics’ tendencies to chalk up hostile critiques of
16 PUNKADEMICS
their work (some lodged by people who may adso be utterly clueless) to anti-intellectualism as opposed to taking them seriously. But more to the point, the perpetual debate over whether its acceptable to ‘intellectualize’ (the offense of academics) punk is a moot point: professors, music jour- nalists and punks themselves have been doing it for well over thirty years. While I have no doubt that the No Future conference, like any other event worthy of the designation, probably featured some obnoxious pan- el titles, a great many jargon-laced presentations, and more than a few cringe-worthy comments, the fact is that there were actually a number of people in attendance — including at least two of the contributors to this book — who had been playing in punk bands, living in punk squats, and being involved in local DIY music scenes years before they ever wore the unlikely moniker of Professor. Along with a few of their fellow “punka- demics” — a term that, unbeknownst to me, was not only thrown around during the UK conference but also used by punk-turned-professor, Greta Snider (San Francisco State University), in a piece she wrote for Maxi- mumrocknroll in 1995 — both Alastair “Gords” Gordon and Helen Red- dington (aka. Helen McCookerybook) have used their unique insights to challenge existing academic work on punk while fostering a broader reas- sessment of punk history and culture that has relevance far beyond the porous borders of the university. Indeed, Reddington cuts to the core of some of the key issues at stake when it comes to research on punk. In an essay that previews the material she would later develop in the book, The Lost Women of Rock Music: Female Musicians of the Punk Era, she writes:
“There is perhaps no better example of male hegemonic control over popular cultural history than the rewrite of punk to exclude the very large and productive presence of young women in the subculture from its very beginning [...] The collective memory of punk recalls young men as spitting, spiky yobs with the occasional nod in the direc- tion of political commitment (until the obligatory signing ceremony with the major label), and young women as fishnet-clad dominatrixes [...] From the writings of aca- demics to the reports of the tabloid press, there is a whole history missing from accounts of punk during this period in
Britain.”””
Whether it’s the excising of women, people of color, and gay/queer- identified folks from punk history or, conversely, the way that punks have used film as a medium to re-write that history and re-think punk’s
ATTEMPTED EDUCATION AND RIGHTEOUS ACCUSATIONS 17
dominant narratives, the process of documentation and analysis (not to mention debate) plays a discernable role in shaping how people under- stand what punk is, whom it is for, and why it is important.?? Max Ward, a veteran hardcore musician as well as the founder/proprietor of 625 Thrashcore Records and current Assistant Professor of History at Middle- bury College, makes this point succinctly: “punk has a culture, and that
culture is defined by how we try to remember our ‘past.’”4
STORIES MATTER
Put simply, the stories we tell about punk matter. In the greater scheme of things, there is clearly much less at stake in the narration of punk than there is, for example, in the stories told about immigration, Indigenous land claims, prisons, or the philosophical and economic un- derpinnings of Neoliberalism. Nevertheless, they matter. Part of the rea- son why is because, like the stories told about other cultural practices and art forms, the relevant work on punk affects the ways we understand its specific histories, its present formations, and its possible future(s). Con- sequently, when the complexities and nuances of punk music, aesthetics and identities are ignored in lieu of sweeping claims and a reliance on problematic assumptions, this has a significant bearing on the ways in which people conceptualize, interpret and draw conclusions about the ‘politics of punk’, youth subcultures, and perhaps the social functions of art and music, as well. The concern here is thus not only the fidelity of the narratives — as in whether the accounts (of bands, scenes, events, etc.) are accurate and truthful — it is also a matter of who gets to speak for whom: whose stories are told and whose are silenced, and perhaps most importantly, who gets to shape public knowledge(s) that inform the ways in which we collectively remember people, events, institutions, ideas, cultural practices and cultural history. In addition, this body of knowl- edge is never only about punk in the first place: in academic research alone one finds discussions of punk situated within larger conversations about the music industry, the changing social status of ‘youth’ in the late 20° Century, the formation of identity, the nature of consumption, and the contentious dynamics of class, race, gender, sexuality and religion that are part of punks’ everyday relationships and also addressed within their own songs, musings, dialogues and debates.
My point here is that the story and mythology of punk get reified over the years as much in academic writing as elsewhere. And it is not just dedicated books and peer-reviewed articles that do this kind of cul- tural work; it is also the hundreds of casual references that academics
18 PUNKADEMICS
make to punk (for example in books on the 1970s or the Reagan Era) that simultaneously support the dominant narratives and constrain the possibilities of analyzing it without the compulsion to either validate its heroes or delineate its pure moment of inception.” Because what gets missed, for instance, in the habitual focus on punk’s origins, its shining stars, its hottest locations, and its most obvious but nonethe- less vital contributions — such as punks’ amplification (with all that the term implies) of independent music and art — are the everyday practices, processes, struggles, ruptures and people that make it so interesting in the first place.
Like the work produced from music journalists, cultural critics, and punks themselves, academic scholarship plays a distinct role in both the cultivation and reproduction of knowledge about punk. While some of this work is admittedly fraught with problems, academics — or, rath- er, punkademics — have also done some of the best work at rethinking punk history, re-conceptualizing its present dynamics, taking issue with dominant scholarly readings of punk politics and punk scenes, and also expanding the parameters of research itself. While much of this research remains cloistered in academic journals and restricted access university libraries, a number of these stories — as well as the storytellers themselves — are widely read and have had an impact on both the ways in which punk is interpreted and the ways that punks see themselves. Notably, this has taken place both from within and outside of The Scene by people who have poked and prodded at the social significance of punk and DIY culture through a variety of different print and digital formats (some- times concurrently). While by no means comprehensive, this book is a contribution to that broader effort.
UP THE NERDS!
One of my primary goals with Punkademics is to encourage a marked shift away from the punk-as-style paradigm that has become so com- monplace in the wake of Dick Hebdige’s Subculture: The Meaning of Style but also from a number of the binary oppositions scholars have used to reduce ‘punk into a static, singular thing that can be mapped along an axis of success vs. failure, resistance vs. recuperation, authenticity vs. inauthenticity, and so on. Instead of producing another series of instru- mental readings of punk that are strictly concerned with what it ulti- mately does or does not do, or what it definitively means or doesn’t mean at one specific moment, or within the confines of one specific scene or musical recording, ’m more inclined to think about what possibilities
ATTEMPTED EDUCATION AND RIGHTEOUS ACCUSATIONS 19
emerge within and through it. Scholarship on punk has sometimes pointed in this direction, though it’s typically focused on which kinds of musical and stylistic hybrids become imaginable or possible through the production of punk music and culture, or somewhat differently, which aesthetic and artistic trends are rendered most visible in punk’s history or that of its precursors. While I am interested in these linkages and the kind of work that, for example, contributors to the book Punk Rock, So What? take pains to highlight, I have always been much more curi- ous about the kinds of subjectivities, people and communities that become imaginable or possible — or perhaps even probable — through DIY punk, ice. the “vectors of punk that strive to escape models of production and consumption otherwise omnipresent in the entertainment industry.””
A fruitful way to approach these interrelationships, as I’ve tried to demonstrate with this very book, is to consider some of the ways that punk maps onto or even organizes certain constellations of cultural practice, artistic expression, ethics, and notions of community. But cru- cially, I think this begins by reframing punk as an object of study and asking some rather different questions about peoples’ relationship to it. Through a combination of essays, interviews, biographical sketches, and artwork, one of the aims of this collection is to do this by way of example as opposed to merely stacking critique on top of critique. While not without its own limitations, Punkademics tries to offer more nuanced perspectives on various aspects of punk and hardcore — and in particular DIY punk music and culture — that stem from contributors’ academic backgrounds as well as their collective participation within and experi- ence of punk scenes.
But of equal importance is the attention focused in the opposite direc- tion, which is back at the university, the classroom, and both the norms and ethics that get embedded into higher education. Given the fact that little research has been done about where punks end up or what their career paths and adventures (as well as struggles and failures) might tell us about punk or why it matters, this book offers some tangible examples that speak to these concerns, inasmuch as colleges and universities func- tion as some of the places where people with ‘punk’ values can ostensibly thrive, or more accurately, where they can potentially put their ethics and ideas into practice; though not without great effort, considerable fric- tion, and at times, complete train wrecks.”” The idea behind Punkademics is thus not only to offer some different perspectives on punk, broadly speaking, but to also tell some entirely distinct stories about academics and punks themselves, and how their priorities and passions get recon- figured by and through their experiences as theorists, artists, activists,
20 PUNKADEMICS
educators and misfits working amidst the often tumultuous landscape of the modern university/edufactory.
1, 2, 3, 4, Go!
NOTES
1 See Zack Furness, One Less Car: Bicycling and the Politics of Automobility (Temple University Press, 2010).
2 Credit for the last line goes to the esteemed Willie Stein. (Sorry to disap- point you, Willie).
3 Any terms used to label specific assemblages of punks and/or punk practices are necessarily inadequate and bound to raise more issues than they resolve. Consequently, I use the terms ‘punk culture’, ‘DIY punk culture’, and ‘DIY punk scene’ interchangeably not out of laziness but because they are simply different ways of talking about the same clus- ters of non-corporate practices, independent institutions, and politi- cized people, however resistant to classification some of them might be. My primary reliance on ‘culture’ instead of ‘subculture’ is, however, de- liberate because I don’t think the term ‘subculture’ can encompass both the punk practices as well as entire “way of life” that is sometimes culti- vated around and through punk. Like the term ‘counterculture’, which I specifically use to designate self-consciously political/politicized cul- tural formations, I used the term subculture where it’s appropriate. Longtime zine writer and punk drummer Aaron Cometbus makes a nice point about the inaccuracy of labels as a point of pride: “T like that about punk and fanzines—that it’s a community that’s very ill-defined. As much as 90% of what we talk about is defining it, and still it’s very ill-defined.” In “Interview with Aaron Cometbus,” Maximumrocknroll, no. 200 (2000). For more on defining and naming punks and/or punk practices, see: Alan O’Connor, Punk Record Labels and the Struggle for Autonomy: The Emergence of Diy (Lanham: Lexington Books, 2008), p. 3; Alan O’Connor “Local Scenes and Dangerous Crossroads: Punk and Theories of Cultural Hybridity,” Popular Music, Vol. 21, No. 2 (2002): 226.
4 Billy Bragg, “Waiting for the Great Leap Forward,” Workers Playtime (Elektra, 1988), LP.
5 On the relationships between urban space and punk, see my discussion of ‘DIY Bike Culture’ in One Less Car, Chapter 6. On the dialectical spa- tialities of hip-hop, see Rashad Shabazz, “Hip-hop and the Black Geo- graphical Imagination,” a talk delivered at Marlboro College, October 13, 2009. Online at http://youtu.be/AJ4Ne-wbxDw
ATTEMPTED EDUCATION AND RIGHTEOUS ACCUSATIONS 21
Roger Sabin, “Introduction,” Punk Rock: So What?, p. 2.
Ibid.
For example, a book like Subculture: The Meaning of Style is often read against, if not held causally responsible for, the tidal wave of shoddy style-as-resistance themed critiques that followed its publication in 1979, and consequently, some of the more complex relationships that Hebdige actually does acknowledge between socioeconomic class, music, ideology and, yes, style receive the short shrift. His argument is problematic in a variety of ways, but certainly not on par with much of the work that reduces his analysis to a close reading of people’s outfits; all the more so when one carefully reads his discussion of the twinned process of ideo- logical and commodity ‘recuperation’ —a concept best defined by the Clash, or perhaps Crass (who used the slogan to critique the Clash), as “turning rebellion into money’—on pages 92-99, under the section heading “Two forms of incorporation.”
In fact, one of the ironies regarding Sabin’s book—aside from leading off with an essay on the Sex Pistols just pages after asking rhetorically, in his introduction, “how many more times must we hear the Sex Pistols story?’ — is that despite the quality of the essays and the authors’ successful effort to demonstrate that “punk was not an isolated, bounded phenomenon, but had an extensive impact on a variety of cultural and political fields,” the book is simultaneously a reminder of some additional trappings that one could also attribute to the ‘orthodoxy’ structuring analyses of punk, such as methodological approaches based almost exclusively on textual analysis (no ethnographies, for example) and a perpetual overemphasis on both British punk and the years 1976-1979.
For an excellent corrective to this trend, see George Hurchalla, Going Underground: American Punk 1979-1992 (Stuart, FL: Zuo Press, 2005). Neil Nehring, “The Situationist International in American Hardcore Punk, 1982-2002,” Popular Music and Society, Vol. 29, No. 5 (2006): 524; Lisa M. Chuang & John P. Hart, “Suburban American Punks and the Musical Rhetoric of Green Day’s “Jesus of Suburbia’,” Communica- tion Studies, Vol. 59, No. 3, (2008): 183-201. Aside from the triviality of calling the band “the Dillinger Four,” Nehring suggests that their sound “fairly distinctively crosses classic punk with sub-genres such as speed- core.” First, ‘speedcore’ is a genre of electronic music (not punk) and, second, no punks have ever used this term to describe punk music, un- less it was a joking reference to an all-tweaker (meth addict) rock-n-roll band haunting some dive bar on the outskirts of Portland, OR. These are among the smallest errors in an essay that largely misunderstands punk as well as its connections to situationist politics. Finally, I also found it
22
PUNKADEMICS
somewhat odd that in Nehring’s attempt to find evidence of D4’s situa- tionist-inspired political and/or artistic critiques, he fails to mention the fact that Paddy — who is shirtless if not naked at every D4 show and in most pictures of the band — has the phrase HOW MUCH ART CAN YOU TAKE? tattooed across his entire chest. It doesn’t get much clearer than that.
There are many examples from which to choose, including the fol- lowing: Ruth Adams, “The Englishness of English Punk: Sex Pistols, Subcultures, and Nostalgia,” Popular Music & Society, Vol. 31, No. 4 (2008): 469-488; Sean Albiez, “Know History!: John Lydon, Cultural Capital and the Prog/Punk Dialectic, Popular Music, Vol. 22, No. 3 (2003): 357-374; Pete Lentini, “Punk’s Origins: Anglo-American Syncretism,” Journal of Intercultural Studies, Vol. 24, No. 2 (2003): 153-174; Geoffrey Sirc, “Never Mind the Tagmemics, Where's the Sex Pistols?” College Composition and Communication, Vol. 48, No. 1 (1997): 9-29; Karen Pinkus, “Self-Representation in Futurism and Punk,” South Central Review, Vol. 13, No. 2/3 (1996): 180-193; Neil Nehring, “Revolt into Style: Graham Greene Meets the Sex Pistols,” PMLA, Vol. 106, No. 2 (1991): 222-237.
Greil Marcus, Lipstick Traces: A Secret History of the Twentieth Century (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1989). Also see Jon Savage, The Englands Dreaming Tapes (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 2010), and especially Jon Savage, Englands Dreaming: Anarchy, Sex Pis- tols, Punk Rock, and Beyond (New York, Macmillan, 2001).
For example, see William Tsitsos, “Rules of Rebellion: Slamdancing, Moshing, and the American Alternative Scene, Popular Music, Vol. 18, No. 3 (Oct., 1999): 397-414; Bradford Scott Simon, “Entering the Pit: Slam-Dancing and Modernity,” The Journal of Popular Culture, Vol. 31, No. 1 (1997): 149-176; Leslie Roman, “Intimacy, Labor, and Class: Ide- ologies of Feminine Sexuality in the Punk Slam Dance,” in (eds.) Linda K. Christian-Smith and Leslie Roman, Becoming Feminine: The Politics of Popular Culture, (New York and Philadelphia: The Falmer Press, 1988), pp. 143-84. With all due and sincere respect to punkademics who have jumped, or rather moshed, their way into this analytic fray (particularly Prof. Tsitsos, who plays in bands and runs a DIY label), I would argue first and foremost for a thorough re-assessment of the problematic. In- deed, the set of kinetic practices under question (moshing, slam-dancing) are not physical performances as much as enigmatic expressions of latent potentialities/possibilities that simply transcend the boundaries of theo- ry’s utility. The ‘wall of death’, for example, is admittedly a fascinating spatio-corporeal phenomenon, if not an elegant, ludic/haptic realization
ATTEMPTED EDUCATION AND RIGHTEOUS ACCUSATIONS 23
of what Henri Lefebve calls a moment: “the attempt to achieve the total realization of a possibility” (Critique of Everyday Life, Vol I, p. 348). But it is nonetheless an eruption of such primal force that, when bounded by the homoerotically charged protocols governing ‘the pit’, becomes wholly resistant to classification and can thus only empty the words used in such vain explanatory efforts from the very meanings which they are employed to signify. Only in its more practical applications elsewhere — for example, when the wall of death is deployed against “the system,” as a tactical/militant adjunct to the anarchist goals of achieving a society based on mutual aid, self-rule, non-hierarchical social relations, and the proliferation of fake meats — could one even begin to effectively grapple with its theoretical implications. See, R.A.M.B.O., Wall of Death the System (625 Thrashcore Records, 2001), LP. For more on the cultural/ political logics of the moshing (“Fuck your individualist mosh / No neoliberals in the pit”) as well as the potential uses of the wall of death against Christian anti-abortion protestors, see Crucial Unit “Thrashahol- ics Unanimous,” and “Wall of Death the Chain of Life,” Crucial Unit/ Municipal Waste, Split LP (Six Weeks Records, 2002).
I have seen no clear evidence that subcultural researchers have ever asked — or even thought to ask — what their research “subjects” actually do call themselves, or what they would like to be called, or why it matters. Punks are creative and quirky; perhaps they would prefer to be known, in peer-reviewed journals, as a “pack,” or a “gaggle,” or even a “murder.” For an exhaustive/exhausting treatment of the politics of subcultural re- search terminology, see most essays from Andy Bennett and practically every monograph or edited collection published in the last fifteen years with variations of words “subculture,” “post-subculture” and also “youth culture” and “club culture” in the title.
John Goshert, p. 87. While I think his definition is insufficient, Goshert offers a notable description of punk (in contrast to singular phenome- non) as “a set of only loosely assimilable vectors and forms of expression.” David Muggleton, Inside Subculture, p. 2. Also see, Andy Medhurst, “What Did I Get? Punk, Memory and Autobiography,” in (ed) Roger Sabin, Punk Rock: So What?, pp. 219-231.
Lucy O’Brien, “Academia in the UK,” The Guardian, September 27, 2001.
Ibid.
Ibid.
Andy Capper, “Anarchy and Peace, Litigated,” Vice Magazine, Vol. 17, No. 8 (2010), p. 99. Online at http://www.vice.com/read/ anarchy-and-peace-litigated-490-v17n8
24
22
23
24
25
26 27
PUNKADEMICS
Helen Reddington, “‘Lady’ Punks in Bands: A Subculturette?” in (eds.) David Muggleton and Rupert Weinzierl, The Post-Subcultures Reader (Oxford and New York: Berg, 2003), p. 239.
These documentaries include Scott Treleaven, Queercore: A Punk-U-Men- tary (Toronto: V-Tape, 1997), VHS; Martin Sorrondeguy Beyond The Screams/Mas Alla de los Gritos: A U.S. Latino Hardcore Punk Documen- tary (Self-released, 1999), VHS; James Spooner, Afro-Punk (Los Angeles: Afro-Punk, 2003), DVD; and most recently, Amy Oden’s film about women in the DIY punk scene, called From the Back of the Room (Self- released, 2011), Film.
Quoted in reference to the compilation, Possessed to Skate Vol. II (625 Productions, 2002), LP. Ward also suggests that the recurring theme of punks recycling ‘old school’ styles similarly relies upon a tenuous rela- tionship to punk history: “Trends come and go...and it seems that every now and then the punk scene harks back to the ‘good old days’ for inspi- ration, which of course is good in some respects. It never is an exact copy of what was [...] because what is being copied is only what we construct from a few record covers, a couple myths, or for those of us old enough, a few fuzzy memories that aren't based in reality.” See Scholastic Deth, “Lyrics and Explanations.” Online at http://www.geocities.ws/scholastic- deth/lyrics.html
For examples of such references, see Bradford D. Martin, The Other Eight- ies: A Secret History of America in the Age of Reagan (New York: Macmil- lan, 2011), pp. 95-118; Bruce Schulman, The Seventies: The Great Shift In American Culture, Society, and Politics (Cambridge, MA: De Capo, 2002), p. 153.
Goshert, p. 88.
It is possible that punkademics could be mapped onto what Linda An- des refers to as the “stages of punk.” Linda Andes, “Growing Up Punk: Meaning and Commitment Careers in a Contemporary Youth Subcul- ture,” in ed. J.S. Epstein, Youth Culture: Identity in a Postmodern World (Oxford: Blackwell, 1998), pp. 212-231. Andy Bennett has written one of the only pieces about ‘old’ punks, but it focuses rather narrowly on fans attending a concert. See “Punk’s Not Dead: The Continuing Sig- nificance of Punk Rock for an Older Generation of Fans,” Sociology, Vol. 40 No. 2 (2006): 219-235.
‘CAUSE | WANNA BE... PHD?
DYLAN MINER AND ESTRELLA TORREZ
TURNING POINT:
CLAIMING THE UNIVERSITY AS A PUNK SPACE!
PUNK AND ACADEMIA are queer bedfellows.” The very nature of this collection presupposes the antagonistic relationship between the autonomy of punk and the structured nature of the university. Any hardcore kid who has spent time in a university classroom will recognize the inherent contradiction be- tween her/his anarchic (and activist) desires to create an alternative and eq- uitable society and the university's ability to restrict all counter-hegemonic voices within it. As professors, we deal with this on a daily basis. We feel this contradiction in our classrooms, in our syllabi, in our research, how we relate with students, and even how we interact with our colleagues. How do we, as punkademics, continue to resist the process of institutionalization, while working within an institution? Moreover, how do we do so when, in the eyes of many students, we represent the power and legitimacy of the university?
Thankfully, we are not alone in our quotidian struggles against the hegemony of dominant institutions. In fact, this everyday struggle is one with roots in the modernist, as well as anticapitalist, tactic to resist the ongoing power of the state and its multiple institutionalized apparatuses. From this position, artists, intellectuals, and activists have frequently been at the forefront of these confrontations. In his discussion of the anarchist-oriented avant-garde, Situationist International (SI), Berlin- based critic Gene Ray comments on the way that modernist artists, whom he places in dialectic tension with the avant-garde, aimed their critiques at institutions, while the anarchist-oriented practices of SI chal- lenged the very legitimacy of institutions by intentionally choosing to not participate in these institutions. According to Ray,
28 PUNKADEMICS
The SI was a group founded on the principle of autonomy — an autonomy not restricted as privilege or specialization, but one that is radicalized through a revolutionary process openly aiming to extend autonomy to all. The SI did not recognize any Party or other absolute authority on questions pertaining to the aims and forms of revolutionary social struggle. Their autonomy was critically to study reality and the theories that would explain it, draw their own conclu- sions and act accordingly. In its own group process, the SI accepted nothing less than a continuous demonstration of autonomy by its members, who were expected to contribute as full participants in a collective practice.
Since Guy Debord, a key situationist and author of The Society of the Spectacle, is common reading in most anarchist and political punk scenes, Ray’s characterization about SI has direct implications on our discussion of claiming the university as a punk space. In fact, Debord and the SI begin to challenge the legitimacy of institutions like the university, the site where punkademics work. Like mainstream arts institutions, the uni- versity, as an institution, frequently inhibits one’s autonomy at the very point when an individual begins to participate in its everyday workings.
As punkademics, which seems to be a fitting title for who we both are, we feel that this intimately fraught relationship between punks and the university is a contest we must individually and collectively confront. In many ways, punk intellectuals, both inside and outside the academy, may turn to the history of Chicana/o or Mexican-American activism as a model of how to compel the institution to work for the people, not only those in power. According to the Plan de Santa Barbara, a 155-page manifesto collectively written by the Chicano Coordinating Council on Higher Education in 1969, “we do not come to work for the university, but to demand that the university work for our people.’”* As insider-out- siders, and as punks and people of color within the university, we are ada- mant that the university be accountable to “our people,” as the Plan de Santa Barbara so significantly articulates. So while we both understand the tactical decision to disavow dominant institutions, such as the uni- versity, we have nonetheless chosen different tactics: to insert ourselves, and our intellectual and cultural labor into the confines of the university in hopes of changing the very nature of the institution.
Conservative pundits, such as David Horowitz, portray the university as an autonomous sphere where old Left intellectuals train and inform new generations of anticapitalist activists. Inversely, we have come to see the
TURNING POINT 29
university as a space that allows only a minimal degree of dissent before dis- carding those rebellious and anti-authoritarian voices which, at one point, may have been allowed to speak. We both have witnessed hostile attacks on friends and colleagues whose ideas were viewed as too confrontational, too challenging, or just too radical for the university. The high stakes examples of tenure dismissal and tenure denial for Indigenous activist-intellectuals Ward Churchill and Andrea Smith are only two examples of times when our allies were denied a space within the university.
Another example is that of Norman Finkelstein, a political scientist writing on the Israel-Palestine conflict. Finkelstein was denied tenure at DePaul University in 2007. For university officials, his critical views on Israeli foreign policy and professional demeanor were deemed against the university's “Vincentian values.” The Illinois Conference of the Ameri- can Association of University Professors (AAUP) criticized DePaul’s de- cision because it felt that the verdict was based on the misconception that Finkelstein’s research “might hurt [the] college’s reputation.”*® I won- der how Indigenous inhabitants feel about the “Vincentian values’ that precipitated missionaries who “came to America to work especially for the salvation of the poor Indians,” as Bishop Joseph Rosati wrote in the nineteenth-century?°
In fall 2010, DePaul was once again in the news following the ten- ure denial of two women of color, an all too frequent event in a labor force which does not formally recognize the unique labor performed by women and faculty of color. One of the women, Namita Goswami, a philosopher of race and postcoloniality was, according to media ac- counts, denied tenure because her work was “insufficiently philosophi- cal.”’ While neither of us know the specifics of these preceding cases, they are each indicative of a system which speaks of institutional “di- versity,” yet is unwilling to re-evaluate the institution’s relationship to counter-hegemonic or challenging forms of knowledge.
In this same way, most institutions of higher education could care less about the things punks care about. Our own identities as punks are intimately intertwined with radical feminism, anticapitalist selforgani- zation, Third and Fourth World liberation, veganism and food justice, and DIY, not even mentioning the most fundamental desire to produce new and liberated societies “within the shell of the old.”* In The Philoso- phy of Punk, Craig O’ Hara discusses the humanizing efforts of punk in a never-ending capitalist world of alienation. He writes that
Punks question conformity not only by looking and sound- ing different (which has debatable importance), but by
30 PUNKADEMICS
questioning the prevailing modes of thought. Questions about things that others take for granted related to work, race, sex, and our own selves...By acting as anti-authoritar- ian nonconformists, Punks are not usually treated very well by those people whose commands to conform are rejected.?
While the university may have the facade of radicalism, it is all too frequently a “free-trade area” where the capitalist model of “intellectual entrepreneurship” supersedes any organic means of knowledge dissemi- nation. With recent budget cuts, faculty have been asked to “tighten our belts” and be “entrepreneurial” by seeking extramural funding for research, the very basis for how the university credits its faculty.
Stuart Hall, the Marxist founder of the Birmingham School who be- gan his career teaching night school to British workers, recognizes the immense authority of capitalism to suck the life from oppositional move- ments, an idea that Slovenian critic Slavoj Zizek has developed to its logical end. For Hall, the conciliatory power of capitalism facilitates the cooptation of any and all oppositional projects into the capitalist model. Hall asserts, “that in order to maintain its global position, capital has had to negotiate, has had to incorporate and partly reflect the differences it was trying to overcome.”'® So punkademics, those of us struggling against capitalist globalization and the university's disavowal of our spe- cialized knowledge, must be doubly cautious about cooptation. Using the language we all understand, punkademics must never sell-out.
Most recently, the university has become a space that proposes the de- velopment of an “engaged global citizenry,” while ignoring the most fun- damental issues of inequality. While punk ontology is founded in, using the language of the anarcho-indigenist Zapatistas of southern Mexico, realizing that otro mundo es possible (another world is possible), dominant institutions are embedded in maintaining existing worlds. As individuals who pride ourselves on being part of a self-constructed and prefigurative society within the shell of the old, punk alternatives do not easily map onto the notions of global citizenship that are being laid out within the entrepreneurial and colonial desires of the university.
It is clear, however, that by documenting these structural changes to the university, we are not naively reminiscing on some ideal past in which the university successfully met the needs of community. Inversely, it ap- pears to us that the university may be more open now than it ever has been, particularly in relation to subaltern knowledges and the position of ethnic studies: programs which are being cut indiscriminately across in- stitutions. Even so, Linda Tuhiwai Smith, a Maori scholar from Aoteoroa
TURNING POINT 31
(New Zealand), positions the development of Western knowledge as one that systematically marginalizes Indigenous knowledge and is active in colonizing global populations. She writes,
The globalization of knowledge and Western culture constantly reaffirms the West’s view of itself as the centre of legitimate knowledge, the arbiter of what counts as knowl- edge, and the source of the “civilized” knowledge. This form of global knowledge is generally referred to as “universal” knowledge, available to all and not ‘owned’ by anyone, that is, until non-Western scholars make claims to it.!!
While many punks come from privileged sectors of dominant society, to identify as a punk is a maneuver to intentionally position one’s self in solidarity with oppressed and colonized people, both locally and globally. A trip to San Cristobal de las Casas, a highland municipality in Chiapas (Mexico) and one of the four cities overtaken by Zapatistas on January 1, 1994, will reveal the high level of crusty punks who have descended on the city. While this may have some negative implications on local community, with Anglo-American and European punks not fully under- standing Mayan indigeneity, it nevertheless demonstrates a profound ad- miration and solidarity with Indigenous struggles. These are movements toward autonomy and ones directly confronting capitalism. In this way, these punks are helping to build another possible world.
Even while institutions attempt to create “global citizens,” the way this commonly transpires disregards the basic pedagogical tools needed to truly open discussions of who this sort of individual may be, why this move is important, and how (as North Americans) we may actually become “engaged global citizens.” One aspect of being a global citizen is commonly interpreted into a crass form of volunteerism. Therefore, each year, thousands of students enter “volunteering obligations” (what was once known as service-learning and then became recognized as civic engagement) without understanding the very systems that necessitate them partaking in such practices. Volunteers enter soup kitchens, home- less shelters, suicide hotline centers and the like spending a few hours (enough to report back to their professor in the form of a power point presentation or final paper) without the rudimentary knowledge that would enable them to critique the capitalist origins of their need to vol- unteer. Of course, this does not mean that all universities practice these in a naive or impractical fashion. At the moment, we both teach these types of courses, educating students about how to engage in solidarity
32 PUNKADEMICS
work with Latino and Native communities in the Great Lakes. To date, they seem to be developing quite successfully.
Instead of evoking a commitment to active social transformation, the university has become a space where corporate colonization impedes and inhibits the (presumably) public space of the university, the inverse of how punk autonomy seeks to ascertain parallel institutions. Although dialogue is at the core of any revolutionary education, the dominant ped- agogical (teaching) mode used within the university classroom remains alienated from any real or authentic learning. This is not to say that the university (and those of us operating within its grasp) does not foster the vision of a new and better world. In many ways, as life-long students and intellectual workers, we wholeheartedly believe that the university can become one of the spaces where we may help to create an alternative universe, one which challenges the dominance of capitalism. This is the reason, we suppose, that there are punks and anarchists operating within the university’s framework, both as students and professors. But all too frequently, this specter haunting academia is simply the veneer of poten- tial democratic engagement.
In turn the university has become adept at pretending to allow resis- tant practices to exist within its structure. These dissenting voices may be politically motivated, such as those identified as anarchist, punk, Marx- ist, council communist, or anti-authoritarian, or their very presence in the university may challenge the status quo (particularly when they are Chicana/o and Latina/o, Black, American Indian, immigrant, working- class, or women and feminists). As many critical pedagogues have cor- rectly argued, including but not limited to Paolo Freire, Antonia Darder, Paul Willis, and Joel Spring, public education has historically been the location where students learn (and accept as natural) their marginal place in the existing social order. From this perspective, schooling is a system of dominance, one that maintains the existing order. This makes us wonder where punks and hardcore kids have learned to accept their/our role on the margins of society?
Although neither of us believe that punk should be mainstreamed and therefore lose its oppositional nature and liberatory potential, we are nonetheless of the opinion that by infiltrating the academy, the presence of punk knowledge systems (we could call these punk epistemologies) will likewise begin to penetrate capitalist infrastructures. Moreover, by alienat- ing certain sectors of society from the university system (or those of us that negate our privilege by choosing not to attend university), we simply begin to accept our own place on the margins of contemporary society. Although we advocate for the creation of parallel institutions, such as free schools
TURNING POINT 33
and open universities, we also believe that punk intellectuals and other radicals must never consent to being denied a place within the university. In this fashion, we must claim the university as a site where knowledge is recognized and will, in fact, help transform contemporary society.
Unfortunately as punks, we continue to self-marginalize ourselves, our views of the world, and the potential role we could play in building a new world. At times, we both minimize our “punkness” so as not to iso- late the other significant perspectives we may bring to the table. We have each had many conversations over the years with friends, acquaintances, comrades, and fellow punks whose base-level knowledge and lived expe- riences were deemed insufficient against those of the university. Forced out by biased and un-accepting professors, many of these punk kids de- cided to leave academia, rather than stay and (re)claim the academy as their own. So at this moment, we stand firm. We demand that the time is now when we begin to declare the university as a punk space.
The tenants of hardcore, as expressed in Craig O’Hara’s The Philosophy of Punk, are based on our collective response to the shared experiences of capitalist alienation, in many the same alienation that all workers of the world share. If we have any hope to circumvent capitalism and the affili- ated processes of corporate globalization, we must begin to use pedagogy (both within and without dominant systems) as a means toward libera- tion. Although we may begin to create alternative infrastructure, which we believe must be amplified, the reclamation of the university must also occur. A two-tiered tactic must include claiming the university work for us, as happened with university students throughout the world in 1968.
Unfortunately, a pessimistic punk orientation only highlights one vantage point of the oppressive nature of schooling. Inversely, education also has the propensity to democratize civil society, a notion that all too many nation-states have used to their benefit. This concept was discussed in-depth by John Dewey, a seminal figure in educational theory. Propa- ghandi, the prominent vegan, anarchist, pro-queer, peace-punk band from Manitoba, posits an alternate relationship between knowledge, eq- uity, and the education system. Accordingly, Propaghandi maintains it in their typical tongue-in-cheek fashion:
At some turning point in history Some fuck-face recognized That knowledge tends to democratize...
We cannot help but comment on how beautifully written (and simul- taneously crass) these lyrics are.
34 PUNKADEMICS
Although the educational system commonly marginalizes and op- presses certain segments of the population — often times the majority — it may also be used to counter these practices. Education, in the eyes of Paulo Freire and his revolutionary text Pedagogy of the Oppressed, is at the core of any radical social change. It is here, in the emancipatory annals of education, where cultural workers choose to either actively work to politicize or depoliticize those that enter the space. As punkademics, we situate ourselves here.
If we, as punk teachers and professors, are truly intent on creating a democratic and equitable society, we must 1) begin to open up what we consider “knowledge” to include punk epistemologies, as well as; 2) begin to infiltrate the university, both as students and faculty, in a way that opens up the university to our knowledge; 3) engage in discussions centered on topics concerning power and privilege; 4) directly confront those notions embedded within a hidden curriculum meant to perpetu- ate a neoliberal agenda; 5) recognize ourselves as agents of change; and 6) enter each social situation as a potential revolutionary act.
By doing so, we amplify what is presently being done both in punk and in some spaces at the university. By doing so, we must prevent the negative progression of the industrial university that produces depoliti- cized (and all-too-frequently precarious) workers. This is not to say that faculty and students who are actively creating radical spaces within the academy do not exist; in fact we do. However we have not fully claimed the university in any critical manner or centralized within one locale. Once punk academics establish intellectual communities that support critical thinking, encourage activist work, and develop alternative fu- tures, the capitalist tide within the academy will begin to change. This book is but the first move in that direction.
NOTES
1 An earlier and abridged version of this article was previously published in the “Teacher’s Column” of Give Me Back #5. The author's would like to thank Fil at GMB, as well as all of the hardcore kids who continue to read zines.
2 While punk is generally queer, only certain sectors of academia operate to queer normative binaries of straightness.
3 Gene Ray, “Toward a Critical Art Theory,” in eds. Gerald Raunig and Gene Ray, Art and Contemporary Critical Practice: Reinventing Institu- tional Critique (MayFly Books, 2009), pp. 84-85.
4 According to the document, this statement is attributed to José Vas- concelos, a problematic and anti-Indigenous bureaucrat during the
TURNING POINT 35
early-to-mid twentieth century. While we do not deny this attribution, we believe that situating within the radical activism of the Chicano move- ment makes more sense for the sake of articulating a punk argument. Sierra Millman, “Students Will Begin Hunger Strike in Support of De- Paul Professors Denied Tenure,” Chronicle of Higher Education, June 25, 2007. http://chronicle.com/article/Students-Will-Begin-Hunger/39107 Joseph Rosati to Nicola Rosati, December 19, 1820, from Barrens, cited in working papers of Frederick Easterly in preparation for his The Life of Rt. Rev. Joseph Rosati, CM (Washington, D.C., 1942) original notes in Mary Immaculate Seminary, Northampton, Pennsylvania.
Rachel Cromidas, “DePaul Faculty Members Call for Tenure Probe.” Chicago News Cooperative, December 7, 2010. http://www.chicagonews- coop.org/depaul-faculty-members-call-for-tenure-probe.
The concept of building a new world within the shell of the old is one created by the Industrial Workers of the World (IWW), a pre-punk and anarcho-syndicalist labor union formed in 1905. The IWW or Wob- blies, as they are commonly known, have been influential on prefigu- rative punk politics and aesthetics. Miner, a long-time Wobbly whose dues are presently unpaid, made a series of relief prints for the 2005 commemoration of the 100th anniversary of the union. These images, some of which were included in Wobblies!: A Graphic History of the IWW (New York: Verso, 2005), traveled to union halls, anarchist bookstores, and alternative spaces throughout North America, Europe, Australia, and South Africa.
Craig O’Hara, The Philosophy of Punk: More Than Noise! (Oakland: AK Press, 1999), pp. 27-28.
Stuart Hall, “The Local and the Global,” in eds. Anne McClintock, Aamir Mufti, and Ella Shohat, Dangerous Liaisons: Gender, Nation, and Postcolonial Perspectives (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota, 1997), p. 182.
Linda Tuhiwai Smith, Decolonizing Methodologies: Research and Indig- enous Peoples (Zed Books, 1999), p. 63.
ROSS HAENFLER
PUNK ETHICS AND THE MEGA-UNIVERSITY
INTRODUCTION ONE SEMESTER IN my Sociology 101 course I noticed a visibly upset student, Christie, sitting in her customary spot near the front of the room. On a typical day she was generous with her contributions to our class discussions, but that day she was quiet and looked to be on the verge of tears. As I wondered what I could have said that so offended her I recalled that she had missed the previous two sessions. I decided to catch up with Christie after class, but before I could ask her to stay she approached me with a folded sheet of paper in her hand. Still holding back tears, she handed me the paper, which I immediately recognized as a funeral program. A picture of a young man stared back at me along with the order of service and directions to the cemetery where he was to be laid to rest. Christie explained that she had missed class to attend her little brother’s funeral and to grieve with her family. Before I could offer my condolences, Christie began apologizing for missing class, pleading that I not count her absences against her. As I looked at her with an expression of sympathy mixed with astonishment, I reminded her that I never penalized people for missing class due to an illness or, especially, a family crisis. Somewhat relieved, Christie told me with a touch of bit- terness that several of her professors had required that she produce the funeral program to “prove” she wasn’t lying about her brother's death. As Christie left I thought What the hell kind of system have we created that a student feels compelled to apologize for attending a funerall?!? Chris- tie’s story is one of many I’ve heard during my years in higher education that reflects the dehumanization running rampant across many large col- lege campuses.
38 PUNKADEMICS
Long before I became a “punkademic’” I was simply a punk. It seemed like every interesting person in my high school — the artists, activists, skaters, musicians, and other outsiders — were connected in some way with the punk scene. More than torn up clothes and abrasive music, punk ideas lured me in, especially the question everything mentality. Hear- ing Nausea call upon us to “Smash Racism” or Downcast rail against white/straight/male advantage in “Privilege” was revolutionary. Listening to Minor Threat sing about the virtues of being “Out of Step” with the world showed me there was more to being young than the booze culture that measured manhood by alcohol content and sexual conquest. Seeing feminist bands like Spitboy and Tribe 8 helped me question patriarchy and homophobia. The punk scene was transformative for me. The op- portunity to continually ask questions, pursue the answers, and examine my own life, made me fall in love with punk and, later, university life. In other words, the same yearning that brought me to punk rock helped me find a home in academia. But just as I was naive about the revolutionary potential of punk so too was I naive about life in the academy.
This chapter follows a punk-themed critique of the modern mega- university and the academic profession based upon the punk values of anti-authoritarianism, nonconformity, creativity/originality, anti-hierar- chy, social change, and the do-it-yourself (DIY) ethic. Based on over ten years of experience as an academic, I discuss how the bureaucratic system creates alienation in the primary academic activities of teaching and re- search. Along the way, I offer possibilities for resistance that punkadem- ics and others might exploit.
PUNK GOES TO COLLEGE:
MEGA-UNIVERSITIES AND PUNK ETHICS
The idyllic image of sagely professor and eager students engaged in Socratic dialogue beneath an ancient oak tree in the midst of majestic stone buildings has on many campuses been supplanted by cavernous, cement lecture halls filled with texting undergraduates and a professor droning into a microphone. Modern “mega-universities” are enormous, mostly state-sponsored research schools that grew exponentially in the post-World War II era, often known as much for their big-time sports teams as for their academic programs. Mega-universities typically have tens of thousands of students (several have over 50,000), huge, com- plex bureaucracies, large class sizes, research oriented professors, and sprawling campuses. I have taught, briefly, at a small liberal arts college and while such places certainly have their own peccadilloes and elitisms
PUNK ETHICS AND THE MEGA-UNIVERSITY 39
they seem to me to serve their students and faculty relatively well in comparison.
Never doubt there are wonderful people doing amazing work at me- ga-universities. However, the system of the mega-university is at best seri- ously flawed and at worst designed to make education efficient and cost effective, alienating students and teachers in the process. Thus, for exam- ple, faculty committed to being wonderful teachers on mega-campuses are often working against a system that pays little more than lip-service to working with undergraduates.
Just as universities have grown, so too has punk, changing from a mostly underground and marginalized scene to an industry where “punk” bands win Grammy Awards. Yet for every Green Day, Blink 182, and Sum 41 that makes it big there are a dozen bands playing in basements and garages to forty kids, seeking to keep alive punk’s countercultural, anti-consumerist roots. Hot Topic, MySpace, and MTV2 might change punk, but they can’t kill its spirit in the underground. Just as punk con- tinually reinvents itself so too can we re-enchant the enlightening spirit lacking in too many the mega-universities.
Critiques of higher education are nothing new. In 1918, Thorstein Veblen described universities of his time as “impersonal,” “mechanistic,” and “dispassionate,” with researchers worshipping value free science just as men of previous eras worshipped mythological gods.’ In 1922, Up- ton Sinclair criticized the plutocratic control of universities by business elites, claiming schools created conformist students ready to take their place in the capitalist machine.” Sociologist C. Wright Mills, believing education was inherently political, took academics to task for conducting and teaching supposedly “value free” social science that in actuality rein- forced the oppressive establishment.’ Similarly, historian Howard Zinn critiqued the “rules” of academia, including “disinterested scholarship,” calling on scholars to “become the critics of the culture, rather than its apologists and perpetrators” and to “work on modes of change instead of merely describing the world that is.’* Numerous feminist scholars re- vealed the academy’s sexist biases and marginalization and exclusion of women and people of color. Page Smith chastised professors for being in “full flight from teaching” and universities for celebrating an “aca- demic fundamentalism” that produces a “poverty of spirit” in its pursuit of unsentimental science.’ Finally, cultural critic and author bell hooks laments an education system that squashes children’s natural predisposi- tion for critical thinking by educating them for “conformity and obedi- ence only.”° My critique shares much in common with these great works but also emerges from my education in punk rock, where my teachers
40 PUNKADEMICS
were the Bad Brains, Dead Kennedys, Born Against, Crass, Fugazi, Biki- ni Kill, and more. Their lessons for me included questioning hierarchies, elitisms, and injustices while committing to originality, creativity, and nonconformity.
RESEARCH
When I mentor undergraduate or MA students about pursuing a PhD I often extol the virtues of an academic life, claiming, “What could be better? You get to choose a topic that completely fascinates you, learn everything there is to know about it, make your own contribution to that knowledge, and hang out with students, sharing what you've learned. And you get paid!” Of course the research enterprise, and more specifi- cally publishing research, is rarely so picturesque. Too often, rather than creating space for groundbreaking, creative, transformative research, the mega-university system pushes faculty towards simply filling arcane aca- demic journals with articles.
Every assistant professor at a mega-university feels the anxious pres- sure dictated by the maxim “publish or perish,” that is, publish your research in respectable peer-reviewed outlets or we will deny you the holy grail of tenure and send you packing. For some young scholars, the publish-or-perish imperative leads to an obsession with quantity rather than quality. “How many “pubs” do you have?” becomes oper- ating directive, regardless of a piece of scholarship’s particular signifi- cance or usefulness. “What have you got in the pipeline?” suggests that article production is an assembly-line-like process, that churning out one piece after another is just part of that process, and that professors are workers fulfilling a monotonous task. One of my past chairs even suggested (in a well-meaning way) that I not aim too highly, just pub- lish in some lower-tier academic journals to fill my tenure “quota.” Yet even meeting some imagined quota of publications might not satisfy, as the next concern becomes where the articles appear: how prestigious the journal or press? Sometimes the mega-university doesn’t even both- er masking the crass commercialism expected of new faculty, judging them not only on their publications but also on their ability to bring in big grants.
Tenure-terror results too often in jargon-laden, esoteric articles dis- connected from reality that only a handful of people in the world can comprehend and even fewer will read. The entire process is stressful, competitive, and alienating. And crossing the tenure finish line hardly ends the status games now firmly entrenched in the young scholar, as
PUNK ETHICS AND THE MEGA-UNIVERSITY 41
one’s professional and self-worth continue to be measured by lines on a curriculum vita.
Even more bizarre are the tenure requirements for “professional en- gagement” which are satisfied by, among other things, presenting work at professional conferences. At their best, such meetings provide a space for colleagues to form new friendships, exchange ideas, be inspired by new research, and wrestle with the current debates in their chosen field. At their worst, they are a train wreck of ill-prepared and poorly-delivered PowerPoint presentations with speakers talking way too fast and yet still managing to not finish in their allotted time. Of course such presenta- tions produce another line on your vita, even if you gave your paper to five people, one of whom left halfway through.
The original punks disdained conventional, commercialized, cookie- cutter music, art, and fashion fed to the “mainstream,” taking a stand for creativity, originality, and innovation. Punk musicians were long skepti- cal of signing to major labels, fearing that record executives — driven by the profit imperative — would push artists to compromise their creative vision. Likewise, young scholars may feel pressure to research something “marketable,” a topic that won't ruffle too many feathers or be perceived as too “political.” Again, given the ominous threat of a tenure review, the many years of schooling, and the difficulty of landing a faculty position, you can hardly blame people for hedging their bets and “cranking out” articles and conference presentations. Still, many of us could remind ourselves that all the effort leading up to landing a job is worthless if we're not pursuing what thrills us rather than tailoring our work to some academic convention.
Here academics might also take a lesson from punk’s anti-elitist roots. One of punk’s early inclinations was to make music and art for everyday people, not for critics or curators and certainly not for rich, high-culture snobs. In academia, sometimes the more jargon-filled and convoluted the writing the higher praise a work receives, as if being obtuse were a virtue designed to deny the plebes some sacred, forbidden knowledge. A certain degree of complicated language and specialized concepts may be necessary to communicate complex ideas, but any honest scholar will admit that academic writing is rife with posturing, due in part, perhaps, to the fear of not appearing smart enough. Why not make our writing less pretentious and more accessible? And why not occasionally write for non-academic audiences — a blog, newspaper editorial, or popular-press book — just as DIY punks spread their work via ‘zines?
Punk taught me to be very critical of social hierarchies, hierarchies of- ten reproduced, rather than challenged, by higher education. Consumed
42 PUNKADEMICS
by the practical considerations of earning a degree (i.e. the cost), I didn’t even consider — didn’t even have the notion to consider — the prestige of one school vs. another. After a successful undergraduate career, I knew I wanted to leap directly into graduate school, but I somehow missed the memo that where you do your graduate work can be just as (or more) important than what you do; prestige of school/department impacts fu- ture job opportunities. During a professionalization seminar in my first year of grad school, I recall the department chair explaining that schools typically hired new scholars from one “tier” below their own prestige and therefore we should give up any notion of teaching at major research universities, regardless of our talent or productivity. Put another way, the “top” schools hire almost exclusively from each other. Even my own field, Sociology, known especially for analyzing (and often critiquing) hierar- chies and unearned privilege, perpetually recreates social stratification by fetishizing “prestige degrees,” that is, giving hiring preference or graduate program slots to people from top-ranked schools. As the punkademic generation assumes the mantle of department and university leadership, will we continue to aggrandize diplomas adorned with the name of a fancy school?
Another punk ideal is a basic commitment to becoming more than a cog in a machine. Yet the modern mega-university is precisely such a machine that manufactures cynicism and dehumanizes its members. Imagine, for a moment, denying someone tenure because they published in the 11" ranked journal rather than one of the top five. Or, spending years researching a topic because it is “hot” or “publishable” as opposed to what truly interests you. If punk teaches us anything it’s that we are too often governed by social rules imposed by a conformist society that cares for little aside from creating more workers and selling more prod- ucts. It’s ironic that academics have more autonomy than many, free to create the lives we want to live, and yet we build and maintain our own prison of status hierarchies and self-imposed competition. Punkademics can hold out for something better.
TEACHING
My first semester of graduate school I was a teaching assistant for a Sociology 101 course servicing 500 students. While the professor was organized, fairly interesting, and even kind, there was simply no way he could reach out to every student. In the modern mega-university, big classes, standardized textbooks, and multiple-choice exams are the norm. As state appropriations for higher ed decline, campuses raise tuition and
PUNK ETHICS AND THE MEGA-UNIVERSITY 43
let in more students to make up the shortfall. The entire enterprise is geared towards efficiency — serve the most students possible with the least amount of expenditure. It’s no secret that smaller classes improve learning outcomes, but it’s also no secret that paying one professor and a few TAs to teach 500 students is cheaper than paying ten professors to teach classes of 50. Some universities are going a step further and replac- ing flesh and blood teachers with computers by expanding their online education programs (less classroom space to build and maintain). The logical extension of the efficiency/profit model is the for-profit ‘universi- ties’ such as University of Phoenix that make little effort to hide the fact that education is, primarily, a business. In short, at the mega-university transformative teaching is sacrificed at the altar of efficiency; students too often feel like a number, a face in a crowd, a customer, rather than a valued member of a learning community.
As the previous section suggests, on most mega-campuses, teach- ing undergraduates takes a far back seat to research (or more specifi- cally, publishing). Some faculty members speak of teaching “loads” as if dealing with undergrads were a burden rather than a privilege. Others purposefully schedule their office hours at inopportune times to avoid being bothered by students. Still others secure grants to help them “buy out” of teaching, freeing them to pursue their (presumably more impor- tant) “work,” while turning over teaching responsibilities to temporary adjuncts and instructors. Exams, especially multiple-choice exams, save hours of grading time but often evaluate rather than educate, driving students to be grade- rather than learning-oriented. I am not suggesting there are no professors who care about teaching; some clearly do care a great deal for their students. Still, the system of rewards — particularly tenure, but also status and raises — favor research production over teach- ing, leading even many well-intended teachers to sacrifice teaching and pursue publishing. The combination of larger class sizes and pressures to publish leaves little time for individual students and little opportunity to forge meaningful mentorship relationships with undergraduates.
Caught up in the same commercialized, McDonaldized system, pro- fessors and students war with one another rather than uniting to pursue their common interests. Each “side” views the other with increasing dis- trust, disinterest, and disdain. Teachers see many students as lazy, apo- litical, looking for shortcuts, often-privileged, and lacking in creativity and any sort of attention span — and sometimes the teachers are right. Students would rather watch reality television or send text messages than read literature or listen to NPR. Students, on the other hand, view teachers as uncaring, boring, rigid know-it-alls who make little effort to
44 PUNKADEMICS
connect their teachings to students’ lived experiences and interests — and sometimes the students are right. Yet the classroom remains one of the most important arenas in which to challenge the shortcomings of the mega-university.
First, and most simply, teachers need to share their passion and ex- citement with students. One of punk and hardcore’s special contribu- tions to the broader music world is the intense, frenetic live show that leaves both performer and audience exhilarated and exhausted. While I have never been in a band, I’ve often considered what it would be like if I taught as if I was fronting a hardcore band. I don’t mean running back and forth at the front of a lecture hall, screaming at students and stage diving into the first few rows. Rather, what would happen if I brought the same level of intensity and communicated the same level of passion I received from a Fugazi show? How would students respond if I taught like the Dead Kennedys played? Granted, such feeling is easier with a receptive, energetic audience. But I was always inspired by a story of Henry Rollins playing with Black Flag. The band had arrived to play a show in some small, midwestern town to find that only a few kids had turned out. Disappointed, Rollins gave a lackluster performance and was later chastised by bandmates who insisted that those few fans deserved the same intense performance Rollins might give to a crowd of hundreds. Rollins took the criticism to heart and committed to playing his guts out for whomever showed up, one person or a thousand. The lesson: even if there is only one eager student in the classroom (and there nearly always is) then that student deserves everything we have.
Inside and outside the classroom, professors have tremendous op- portunities to build relationships with and among students in defiance of the inhuman, bureaucratic mega-university. Virtually any punk can compare and contrast “concerts” and “shows”; a concert is big, relatively anonymous, and features professional, godlike musicians performing for mere mortals (a.k.a. fans), while a show involves an intimacy between performer and audience: a symbiotic, energetic relationship between equals. Concerts feature barriers and security guards between the band and the crowd; shows allow performer and audience to become one as the singer passes the mic to kids while others dive into the audience from the stage. The distinction is significant. Sometimes we have literal barriers between us and our students: podiums, tables, and empty spaces at the front of a lecture hall. More often we have symbolic barriers: cre- dentials, status, and “expertness.” Overcoming these barriers is crucial to transforming the hierarchical teacher-student relationship. There are many possibilities. Using reusable nametags throughout the semester can
PUNK ETHICS AND THE MEGA-UNIVERSITY 45
help everyone, teacher and students, get to know one another. Having everyone introduce themselves and shake hands on the first day begins the process of connection. Creating a challenging, but validating, space that welcomes student conversation and participation builds rapport and encourages students to find their voice; imagine a classroom where everyone thinks of her/himself as both student and teacher. Allowing and encouraging students, whenever possible, to pursue their own in- terests, rather than completing prefab assignments, fosters imagination and ownership over their work. Above all, bringing originality, humor, and, especially, creativity to the classroom sparks student engagement while humanizing what is too often a very sterile, predictable academic atmosphere.
Finally, the classroom can be a place to imagine a more just and sus- tainable world: a place where professors can, as bell hooks suggests, teach to transgress. While early punks were often extremely cynical, espousing a “no future” attitude that reflected their often dismal and hopeless sur- roundings, many punks have since committed to social change in one form or another. Cultural critics and former punks have been tolling punk’s demise since 1979. But perhaps, as Dylan Clark suggests, “The threatening pose has been replaced with the actual threat.”” My educa- tion in social justice really began with punk rock. At my high school, punks dominated Amnesty International, the student environmental group, and the opposition to the Gulf War. They were anti-racist, pro- feminist, and often vegetarian or vegan. More recently, bands like Good Riddance supported animal rights and radical politics; NOFX’s Fat Mike rallied youth to vote against George W. Bush in 2004; and Rise Against championed environmental and animal rights causes.
At its core, punk is about anti-conformity and countering hegemony. Punkademics are especially situated to help students question everything. But being a nonconformist simply for the sake of being different is a shallow form of resistance. Instead we can find inspiration in Martin Luther King, Jr.’s call that we be “transformed nonconformists,” radically challenging the status quo — militarism, sectarianism, racism, and pov- erty — in meaningful ways.* In the humanities and social sciences we can reveal the inequalities of race/class/gender/sexuality and debate alterna- tives. In anthropology and international studies courses we can challenge students’ ethnocentrism and nationalism. In economics classes we can question the excess, exploitation, and inequalities of capitalism but also move beyond knee-jerk anticapitalist rants. In political science we can teach students to decode politicians’ and pundits’ lies, while in math courses students could study how leaders use statistics to persuade and
46 PUNKADEMICS
mislead. In chemistry and biology courses we might critically consider the role of biotech and genetically engineered food in our future. English courses can explore marginalized writers and encourage students to find their own voice. The opportunities to educate for critical thinking and personal transformation are limitless. Students will remember the feeling of the course along with the facts, and, like a great punk show, no one will remember a few missed notes.
STUDENTS Much of this chapter has focused on the role that faculty and the university structure play in creating the dehumanizing mega-university experience; after all, individual students come and go, faculty, admin- istrators, and university agendas persist. Nevertheless, students are not powerless puppets or mindless zombies; they will play an especially cru- cial part in any potential resistance or reforms. They must take a DIY approach to their education, actively creating a meaningful experience in spite of the mega-university. If you are a student, you might try these ideas:
¢ Get to know a few of your professors, early on! Visit them during their office hours, and not only when you have a problem or a complaint about a grade.
¢ Think like a student, not a robotic consumer. Yes, a degree will serve you well in your future career, but education is more than grades and credentials.
¢ Pour your energy into the classroom! Pay attention, answer ques- tions, debate. Students outnumber the teacher; your energy im- pacts everyone's experience.
¢ Find out about the stellar teachers on your campus; take their classes; and nominate them for teaching awards.
* Question your beliefs. Approach your classes with “beginner's mind,” letting go of your preconceptions while thinking critically about course material.
¢ Be creative! Take risks! Approach your professors with your own ideas for projects or independent study.
¢ — Put down your smart phone. Just for a bit. Not every class session will blow your mind, but it would be tragic if you missed a trans- formative discussion because you were updating your Facebook page.
e Seek an intentional community. Mega-universities can make us feel anonymous and insignificant, but there are always small
PUNK ETHICS AND THE MEGA-UNIVERSITY 47
pockets of interesting, engaged people. Many schools have residential colleges, an Honors program, a music scene, and of course, numerous student organizations and clubs.
¢ Agitate! Work for progressive change on your campus, in your community, and for the world.
CONCLUSION
A wise mentor and award-winning mega-university teacher once told me that universities were full of people creating suffering for each other. Whether it’s the professor proclaiming with pride on the first day that half the class will fail the course, or the student who plagiarizes a paper or gives a prof undeserved poor reviews, there is plenty of antagonism to go around. The mega-university is a creature of our own making: a monster that has escaped the control of its makers. But we can take it back.
I believe punk is to some degree about recognizing and reconnecting with our humanity and the humanity of others. Punk calls us to resist the dehumanizing systems that crush not just our individuality and creativ- ity but also our compassion and ability to connect with people. Down- cast tore apart the American Dream in “System,” suggesting “Society must dig to the root of the problem: separation — again rearing its ugly head.” 7 Seconds asked that we learn to “walk together,” honoring our differences while realizing our connections. Too often in contemporary life, people become tools, obstacles, annoyances, and cartoonish carica- tures to be used, degraded, or simply ignored entirely. A good punk show is more than strange hairdos, obnoxious music, and circle pits: it’s an indescribable feeling, an emotional experience made meaningful because it is shared. More than superficial individualism, punk is a way of fight- ing not only our own alienation but also our separation from our fellow human beings. While a university may never duplicate such feelings, it offers its own arena in which to build community.
Perhaps a truly punk rock response to the mega-university would be more revolutionary than some of the reforms I have proposed here. My aims are fairly modest because I have witnessed both the resistance to change and the transformative potential of universities firsthand. I be- lieve that punk, despite its many shortcomings, has provided many of us a space to grow into the people we hope to be, rather than becoming just what society expects of us. And I believe that universities can do the same. Inspired by underground punk, we can rekindle the habit of undermining hierarchy, questioning authority, and defying convention. And we must do it ourselves.
48
PUNKADEMICS
NOTES Thorstein Veblen, The Higher Learning In America: A Memorandum On the Conduct of Universities By Business Men (New York: B.W. Huesbsch, 1918), p. 5. Upton Sinclair, The Goose Step: A Study of American Education (Pasadena: Self-published, 1922). C. Wright Mills, Zhe Sociological Imagination (Oxford: Oxford Univer- sity Press, 1959), pp. 50-75. Howard Zinn, “The Uses of Scholarship,” in The Zinn Reader: Writings on Disobedience and Democracy (Seven Stories Press, 1997), p. 541. Page Smith, Killing the Spirit: Higher Education in America (New York: Viking, 1990), pp. 5-7. bell hooks, Teaching Critical Thinking (New York: Routledge, 2010), p. 8. Dylan Clark, “The Death and Life of Punk, the Last Subculture,” in eds. David Muggleton and Rupert Weinzierl, The Post-Subcultures Reader, (New York: Berg, 2003), p. 234. Martin Luther King, Jr., “Transformed Nonconformist,” Strength To Love (New York: Harper and Row, 1963), pp. 8-15.
ZACK FURNESS AND MILO J. AUKERMAN
MILO WENT TO COLLEGE:
AN INTERVIEW WITH A DESCENDENT
DON’T WORRY ABOUT AN IMAGE DON’T GOT NO ATTITUDE
| KNOW | WON'T GET LAID
IF | WON'T BE LIKE YOU
DON’T GOT NO BICEPS
DON’T GOT NO PECS
BUT PLL READ YOU UNDER THE TABLE WITH MY THICK SPECS!
-DESCENDENTS, “MASS NERDER”
FOR ANY PUNK who came of age in the 1980s or 1990s, Milo Auker- man hardly needs an introduction. As the singer and front man for the influential U.S. punk band, the Descendents, Aukerman’s clever wit and catchy vocals helped the band carve out a musical niche that lay some- where between the aggressive hardcore musicianship of Black Flag, the toilet humor of a moody 15-year old Ramones fan, and the pop sensi- bilities of 60s rock bands that long permeated the Southern California beach town culture from which the band emerged. It is the unique inter- pretation of such elements that, in hindsight, has arguably most defined the Descendents legacy as hundreds of bands routinely cite their ang- sty, love-scorned, caffeine-fueled melodies as part of the bedrock upon which the genre of ‘pop punk’ was built. However, of equal significance is Milo himself, whose unpretentious demeanor and heart-on-the-sleeve
50 PUNKADEMICS
lyrical forays became part of a persona that was as equally defined by his notoriously bookish looks. Yet unlike the self-consciously ‘outsider’ im- age cultivated by imitators of Elvis Costello and DEVO, one could tell early on that Milo’s tussled hair and thick black glasses were not part of ‘a look,’ rather, it was simply how he looked. It is for this very reason — ie. the most honest expression of not giving a shit — that Milo almost singlehandedly, if not unintentionally, forged the “geek chic” mold for punk rockers years before Rivers Cuomo (Weezer) and droves of thick- rimmed hipsters learned to wear their inner nerd like a badge of honor. One could argue that too much has been made of Milo’s role as the “gangly bespectacled” front man, or for being, as one interviewer boldly put it, the “nerd king of punk rock.”! Then again, not every punk band documents their singer’s scholastic pursuits in the title of their first LP (Milo Goes to College) or actively promotes a cartoon image of his likeness — replete with boxy spectacles, a dress shirt and tie — as their enduring visual icon. And most certainly, not every punk vocalist spends his time between records and touring — over a 30-year span, no less — in pursuit of a Microbiology PhD and, eventually, a career as a research scientist.
As a torchbearer for nerdy rockers and a pioneer of the PhD/punk juggling act that few musicians in the scene have attempted to pull off, Dr. Milo J. Aukerman is the godfather of punkademics. Indeed, when I first kicked around the idea for this book some years ago, it was partly as a response to the fact that I was singing in a band, working on my PhD, and would periodically find myself in conversations — typically outside of shows — where small talk about my job inevitably lead to someone making a Milo reference. On one occasion, | remember a guy introduc- ing me to his friend as the “PhD punk” who was “doing the Milo thing.” Recently, I got the chance to ask Milo some questions about how his ‘thing’ is done.*
ZACK FURNESS: As I was reading through some of the interviews youve given over the last 10-15 years, I noticed a trend whereby the interviewer asks you a token question about your PhD, but he or she never wants to get into the nitty-gritty of it all. This always bothered me because science and education are obviously big parts of your life, and they have also defined the persona of the Descendents, to some extent. In addition, Im a nerd and am largely fascinated by the endeavors of other nerds, especially when the person in question happens to front a legendary punk band. So I guess the best place to start is by asking: what kind of work do you do as a biochemist, and how did you first get interested in the field?
MILO WENT TO COLLEGE 51
MILO AUKERMAN: I work on plant genes, trying to identify genes that help plants be more tolerant to drought or nutrient deficiency. On a day-to-day basis, I work a lot with DNA (plant or bacterial), which suits me just fine...that’s how I got interested in this area. I was doing an oral report in high school and chose to talk about DNA, and got hooked on the subject. In fact, that was right about when I was getting into punk rock, so the two passions of my life competed with each other from the very beginning!
ZF: Who are your scientific heroes?
MA: My scientific heroes are Francis Crick, the co-discoverer of DNA, and Sydney Brenner, the co-discoverer of the genetic code.
ZF: It seems like you were the first well-known punk to earn a PhD. To your knowledge, were there others who blazed the punkademic trail before you? And were there also punks that gave you shit for it?
MA: The closest thing to a predecessor I can think of is DEVO, who I liked (not ashamed to admit it...this was before I discovered Black Flag and the Germs). Although they were not academics per se, DEVO were clearly nerds and even mentioned DNA in a song or two, so that was good enough for me! I can’t say they inspired me to get an education, but they made it okay to be a nerd and like new wave/punk rock. I never got any shit for the school thing, probably because it seemed like such a natural transition for me...Bill (Stevenson, the drummer) pretty much knew all along I was going to do college, for example.
ZF: Its obvious that you were very interested in science classes when you were in college, but what were some of the other courses or writers that you really enjoyed?
MA: I took a poetry class where I formulated some of my most embar- rassing and bombastic lyrics “Impressions,” for example). I also minored in music literature, and got exposed to classical and experimental music. I actually failed a course on Wagner; I couldn't relate to him as a hu- man being. Berg, on the other hand, I loved, especially Wozzeck. I also remember reading Herbert Marcuse’s Aesthetic Dimension and relating to the idea that true art by necessity transcends politics.
ZF: Youve written a number of songs about struggling with growing up, and in reading the lyrics to a song like “Schizophrenia,” its pretty clear that youve
52 PUNKADEMICS
also had some past difficulty reconciling your passions for music and science. What made you finally decide to pursue the latter on a full-time basis (aside from the obvious fact that punk doesn't exactly pay the bills)?
MA: It was the “long look” — what could I see myself doing in my 50s, 60s, etc. Not very punk, I know. The reality was, I got just as excited about biology as I did about punk rock, but only one of those two you could actually make a career out of, at least in 1982, anyway. What I didn’t realize is that the music addiction is hard to shake; I tried hard to leave it behind but always found myself coming back to it.
ZF: Are you happy with the choices youve made?
MA: Considering the on-again-off-again nature of my approach to music, I’m surprised it worked out as well as it did. I sometimes regret not hav- ing chosen music as a full-time career (after all, the Basemaster General states we should always try to achieve ALL in whatever we do). But I’ve always thought that as long as ’'m doing something creative, it doesn’t matter whether it’s music or science, or both. So I’m OK with how it all turned out.
ZF: Most of the punks Ive met who were/are grad students or professors are in the humanities or social sciences, though I've also worked outside of a research university for the last four years. Have you met many other punk scientists?
MA: Greg Graffin (Bad Religion) is a professor of Biology at UCLA. Dexter Holland (Offspring) is another punk scientist, although he never finished his PhD. He got a Masters from USC, and once told me if he ever wanted to go back and get the PhD, he'd just go give the school a huge chunk of money!
ZF: How do most scientists respond when they find out about your other’ career, or listen to your band? For example, has anyone ever brandished a Descendents tattoo in front of you at a conference, or have you ever been propositioned to be in an all-scientist punk band?
MA: When I interviewed for my science job, two funny things happened. First, I had to give a seminar, and afterwards a few employees who were Descendents fans came up to get an autograph, which made me look re- ally good to the hiring committee! Second, I let it slip that I was going to jump on stage with ALL that same night, and so a few members of the
MILO WENT TO COLLEGE 53
hiring committee actually came to the show. It was like “Part Two” of the job interview! So I feel blessed to be associated with some scientists who have an open mind, and like to rock out. Now, playing with scientists in a band is another matter. The temptation would be to write a magnum opus to DNA, and that is something to be avoided...I mean there’s nerd, and then there’s SUPERnerd, and I can’t go there.
ZF: Have you ever wanted to be a professor?
MA: That’s what I went to grad school for, but I found myself in the position to take an industry job, and I went for it. It was totally the right decision for me, and now academia doesn’t sound so appealing. I have no tenure battles, no grants, no teaching to do, only research. In exchange, a loss of some autonomy, but a fair trade in my estimation.
ZF: [ve met a lot of really smart people in the punk scene throughout the last 15 years and, on the whole, I tend to think of punks as being more well read and politically aware than their peers, particularly when it comes to young people. At the same, punk hasn't exactly been considered an “intellectual” af- fair throughout its history, and there are numerous examples of punk bands that take a certain degree of pride in being anti-intellectual. Have you no- ticed any changes over the years? Has punk become nerdier?
MA: Lyrically, the Descendents are probably more anti-intellectual than a lot of other bands; I mean we have multiple songs about farting. Then there’s the Germs, who were one of the more intellectual bands lyrics- wise, but this intelligence was overshadowed by Darby’s excesses. It does seem like lyric matter has become more high-minded of late, especially the political-leaning bands. But as for nerdiness, I think it’s always been a part of punk, not from the cerebral point of view, but more viscerally. When I celebrate the nerd in punk rock, it’s as much for the spastic, outcast nature of a nerd as it is for the intellectual connotations. There’s a danger of thinking too much, when what we really need is to spazz out.
ZF: While the general public isn’t all that conversant on the subject of plant biochemistry, there is an increasing level of controversy (particularly outside
the U.S.) regarding the implications of bioengineering crops...Im thinking of debates over the development and use of GMO crops, and the patenting of particular forms of plant life. Does your specific work on plant genetics force
you to stake out positions on these issues, or ones like them? Is there a particu-
lar set of ethics or politics that inform your research?
54 PUNKADEMICS
MA: I don’t work directly on a crop plant, but a weed called Arabidopsis. I view my research as more basic in nature, i.e. acquiring knowledge about the organism. Nonetheless, there is an applied angle to everything I do, and this definitely leaves me open to criticism from anti-GMO people. As you implied, GMO plants are currently accepted by a good portion of the American public; does this mean theyre OK? All I can say is that breeders have been creating “recombinant plants” for many decades without controversy, using traditional genetics; we are not doing anything radically different from that. And there are definitely checks and balances against creating so-called “monster” plants; the USDA makes sure of that. My feeling is, technological advances in agriculture will be essential in order to boost crop production enough to feed an ever-growing world. No risk means no boost in production and more starving people, and that is a much worse fate.
ZF: Can biochemistry help us to achieve ALL?
MA: MUGMUGMUG. ...of course! Having said that, I’m a firm believer in moderation. Do what you need to get that edge, but don’t go over the edge. Too much, and youre only achieving ALL in your head, but not in reality.
ZF: I assume that the Descendents and Bad Religion have shared the stage more than a few times, and Im curious about your encounters with fellow punkademic, Greg Graffin. Have the two of you had the opportunity to prop- erly geek out together? Because I have an image in my head of the two of you frenetically discussing the nuances of animal & plant biology on a tattered couch in the backstage of a shitty club, while surrounded by tattooed drunk punks who are either confused, intrigued, or both. Has this scene ever played itself out?
MA: It’s odd, but I don’t think I’ve ever met Greg. He’s a great singer and lyricist (I loved Suffer), but actually we inhabit two separate biological spheres, so I don’t know if we'd be able to geek out too much. I would be interested in hearing how he handled post-PhD life in academia, i.e. whether it met his expectations (I can say for me, it didn’t).
ZF: Can you name the chemical composition of caffeine off the top of your head?
MA: I remember making a point of knowing this when I was an under- grad. One night, after too many bonus cups [of coffee] mixed with beers,
MILO WENT TO COLLEGE 55
I tried to draw out the chemical reaction of caffeine with ethanol (poor man’s speedball?)...I think I ended up with putrescine as an end product. Ah, college days.
ZF: If punk could be isolated as a chemical compound, what would it look like?
MA: My rendition of the ultimate punk protein is below; I call it the FTW protein. The “zinc finger” is an actual structure found in certain regulatory proteins, and there also exists a related protein structure called a “zinc knuckle.” The FTW protein consists of four zinc knuckles and one zinc finger, in a tandem array. The placement of the zinc finger in the middle position is crucial for its function...and, of course, its function is self-explanatory.
Oo 0
of
56
PUNKADEMICS
NOTES Rick Reger, “Descendents Still Playing By Own Rules,” Chicago Tribune, December 2, 1996; Mike Powsner, “Milo Aukerman: The Nerd King of Punk Rock,” Yo Beat #8 (Summer, 1998). Online at http://www.yobeat. com/aukerman.htm.
Thanks to Andy Cornell for contributing ideas for questions.
RYAN MOORE
ON BECOMING A PUNK ROCK SOCIOLOGIST
1 WAS BORN in Long Beach, CA and raised in the adjacent city of San Pedro, graduating from San Pedro High School in 1988. Id like to be able to tell you all about how I was influenced by our hometown heroes, the Minutemen, or Black Flag, or the Descendents, or any of the other hardcore bands that emerged from the nearby cities of Los Angeles’ South Bay at this time. I can imagine a really good story about how the radical politics and do-it-yourself ethic of the local hardcore scene would inspire me to become the Marxist sociologist I am today. However, that story would be a lie, because the truth is that my paths to both punk rock and radical sociology were never that direct or linear. And, I’m just not that cool.
In high school I was a devout partisan of thrash metal bands like Slayer, Metallica, Anthrax and a couple dozen others with a more limited following. By the second half of the 1980s the California hardcore scene had fizzled out. There was this one punk dude who had “Minor Threat” written on the jacket he wore to school every day, but I didn’t know any- thing about them because the only people I hung out with were other longhairs and stoners. Still, there was a lot of punk influence in thrash metal, which was less about devils and dragons and more about indict- ing real world authorities, creating a local scene with indie record labels, and maintaining a veneer of authenticity that mocked the posturing and pomposity usually associated with heavy metal
My headbanging roots notwithstanding, I almost voted for George Bush in the first election I was old enough to vote in, until my mother talked me out of it at the last minute. Like many other metal heads, I was personally rebellious but my half-baked political views amounted to nothing more than simple, knee-jerk libertarianism. I was entranced by power, enthralled by violence, and envious of wealth, and I also hated
58 PUNKADEMICS
people I thought were weak or dependent, so it probably isn’t surprising that I almost voted for Bush.
I had begun college during that fall of 1988, as my parents were eager for me to leave my troublemaking metal friends behind and move north to attend San Jose State University. It wasn’t long before I found myself in classes taught by veterans of the New Left. One of them was Professor Douglas Dowd, who had been part of the Monthly Review editorial team with Paul Baran and Paul Sweezy and cofounded the National Mobiliza- tion to End the War in Vietnam. Dowd would typically begin his classes in Microeconomics with some thoughts about Marx or Ricardo before launching into a series of tirades that indiscriminately covered everything from the wastefulness of capitalism to the insanity of war and national- ism to the cruelty of child labor. This 70-plus year-old man would yell and point and curse and then stop suddenly, look out the window, and silently shake his head while muttering something about the insanity of our world. Many of the students in class were horrified and stopped at- tending after the first two weeks, but I was captivated. One day Dowd recited the lyrics to John Lennon's “Imagine” and asked the class if that sounded like the kind of world any of us would want to live in, and I was the only student to raise my hand. “Then youre a God-damn Com- munist!” he shouted at me.
O.K., so I guess ’m a Communist now. This was admittedly a major political about-face, but to this day I think my metal roots and cultural rebelliousness prepared me to embrace this stigmatized, marginalized po- litical identity. I had grown up in a working-class seaport with a vague sense that the world wasn’t right, and now I was engrossed in my educa- tion to try and understand why. I was listening to the Bay Area’s progres- sive radio station KPFA and reading everything I could get my hands on, especially Howard Zinn’s A People’s History of the United States. My identity and style morphed from headbanger to something like a retro countercultural radical as I became absorbed in Todd Gitlin’s The Sixties: Years of Hope, Days of Rage and anything else I could read or watch about the Sixites, Students for a Democratic Society, and the counterculture.
I enrolled in a social theory class the following semester, and it was there that I read Marx for the first time and met my friend Mike Rob- erts, who today is also a Sociology professor at San Diego State. Mike and I started a left campus organization and worked on publishing a newspaper that was unfortunately sabotaged by some other students just before it was about to be printed. Our social theory professor, Talmadge Wright, had also started a group called the Student Homeless Alliance in which we became involved. This was late 1990, and the United States
ON BECOMING A PUNK ROCK SOCIOLOGIST 59
was gearing up for our first war with Iraq, so Mike and I began working with other campus activists to create an anti-war coalition and organize an anti-war demonstration. I experienced my first 15 seconds of fame when my speech commencing the demonstration was sound-bitten for the local TV news.
At this time I knew a lot of people who were into punk rock, but my tastes hadn’t progressed that far yet. Some of my friends regularly made trips up to Berkeley to go to the Gilman Street club, but I never went. They played Dag Nasty, Green Day, and Big Drill Car for me but I absolutely hated all that melody. I thought it was cool that Bad Religion could reference Noam Chomsky and the like, but to this day their singer’s voice drives me crazy. One of my roommates was really into Fugazi, and although they've since become one of my favorite bands they just didn’t compute to me at that time. What my metal years had prepared me for was grunge and the whole Sub Pop/Seattle scene, so of course I took to Mudhoney and Soundgarden almost instantly. And then more locally there was Primus, Mr. Bungle, Psychefunkapus, the Lim- bomaniacs, and a bunch of other bands that formed a metal-funk-punk scene in the Bay Area.
By now my career goals had changed such that I wanted to go to graduate school and hopefully grow up to be a tenured radical like my professors. UC Santa Cruz was known to have a lot of Marxist and radi- cal faculty members, especially in the Sociology department, and so | transferred there in the fall of 1991. I did an internship with Capital- ism, Nature, Socialism, the journal of Marxist ecology founded by James O’Connor, and worked with the Bay Area activist Frank Bardacke on a project about farm workers. Other than that, however, there were a lot of people who talked radical politics at UC Santa Cruz but there wasn’t a lot of action — a possible result of the campus’s relatively isolated loca- tion in the mountains of central California. I joked with friends: if a bunch of students demonstrate in the forest and there is no TV crew there to film them, do they make a sound? My only brush with revolu- tion was accidentally getting hit in the side of the head with some sort of firecracker on the night of the Rodney King riots as the Santa Cruz students marched into town and trashed the local police department headquarters.
Nirvana’ Nevermind came out during my first semester at Santa Cruz. I remember that for weeks I would walk around the dorms and count how many rooms were blaring “Smells Like Teen Spirit” or some other song from the album. I knew it was a really big deal when the dreadlocked hippie kids who spent all day playing hacky sack and, as far
60 PUNKADEMICS
I knew, listened to nothing but reggae and the Grateful Dead were sud- denly talking about how much they wanted to see Nirvana when they came to San Francisco. The next two years or so would represent the pin- nacle of the alternative rock/Lollapalooza era. Then the questions began: Did Nirvana sell out? Is alternative the new mainstream? Did I really just see a runway model wearing Doc Marten’s? Does anyone know anyone who likes to be called “Generation X”? Did that douchebag on the TV really just tell me that the new Subaru Impreza is just like punk rock?
At Santa Cruz I took a great class in the history of U.S. imperial- ism in Central America, read the Frankfurt School for the first time, and wrote research papers about the Black Panthers, American foreign policy, and the Wobblies. But by this time I had also been introduced to cultural studies, both in my courses on mass media and popular culture and in my conversations with activists who were influenced by iden- tity politics and postmodernism. My relationship to cultural studies, as I discuss in more detail below, has always been deeply ambivalent. In the context of all these questions about alternative culture and Generation X, I could see that the issues raised by cultural studies about youth subcul- tures, hegemony, and resistance were still very pertinent and could not be ignored. I was especially taken with Lawrence Grossberg’s We Gotta Get Outta This Place, which as any reader of the book knows, is loaded with pomo jargon but still raises what I thought were prescient questions about postmodern society, the ironic cynicism of youth culture, and the role that these phenomena had somehow played in maintaining the he- gemony of conservatism.
I wrote a senior thesis under the direction of Professor Herman Gray about the media coverage of the movement against the Gulf War and graduated from UC Santa Cruz in the spring of 1993. I was on my way to graduate school and chose to enroll in the Sociology program at UC San Diego because it advertised itself as having a strong emphasis in culture, which had quickly become my main field of interest. My first two years of graduate school were a rude awakening. I had chosen to study sociology because as an undergraduate it seemed so interdisciplin- ary and open-ended, like it was the best of all possible homes for my combination of interests in critical theory, radical politics, social history, and cultural studies. But as a graduate student I quickly discovered that professional sociology was a different animal altogether.
In time I learned that the Sociology department at UC San Diego had indeed specialized in culture at one point in its history, but in recent years there had been a major shift toward historical-comparative sociol- ogy, and those faculty always seemed to be repeating the mantra that they
ON BECOMING A PUNK ROCK SOCIOLOGIST 61
were trying to make the program more “professional,” “competitive,” and “rigorous.” Yuk. Moreover, what the department did offer in terms of culture was mainly rooted in the apolitical traditions of microsociology like symbolic interactionism and ethnomethodology. Double yuk. For- tunately, critical theory and cultural studies had made strong inroads in UCSD’s departments of communication and literature, and in ethnic studies I discovered Professor George Lipsitz, who would serve as a de facto mentor in my study of neo-Marxist theories of culture.
San Diego was home to a bustling alternative music scene centered at a club called the Casbah, and I began going to shows there on a regular basis. After the success of Nirvana and other grunge bands, the major labels had gone scouting for new alternative rock acts to sign, and San Diego was one of a number of cities that was pegged as a potential “next Seattle.” Seven San Diego bands had signed with major labels during this time, and everyone from Rolling Stone to Details to the E! Television Net- work had done feature stories about the local scene. Beyond the hype, I discovered that there was indeed an exciting and musically diverse scene, and I instantly became a fan of the spastic noise of Trumans Water, Drive Like Jehu, and Heavy Vegetable, the retro punk of Rocket From the Crypt, and the cyborg prog rock of Three Mile Pilot.
I was beginning to envision a dissertation project that brought to- gether the cultural studies focus on music and subcultures with the so- ciological methods of ethnography and the neo-Marxist inquiry into the place of culture in post-Fordist capitalism. How all those pieces of the puzzle actually fit together would be something I would have to figure out along the way. Unfortunately, most of my sociology professors were vocally unsupportive of this idea. I had impressed many of them with my self-motivated interest in social theory, but for them music was a frivolous concern without any real sociological import. When I told the professor in my field methods seminar what I planned to do, he replied with a snarky tone, “It sounds like you're just going to hang out with your friends.” Another one begged me to do something else — anything else, really — because I was “too close” to my project, and he eventually removed himself from my committee when I refused.
In actuality, I didn’t have any friends inside the scene, and rather than being “too close” I constantly felt like an outsider because not only was I not a musician, I was this geeky grad student who had all these esoteric theoretical and political questions about music and the scene. Lots of people told me that my project sounded like “fun,” and it was fun to go shows and hear live music in what I thought was a great scene, but it was nerve-wracking as hell to approach these people in a club and awkwardly
62 PUNKADEMICS
ask them if we could arrange an interview. Let’s just say I found myself drinking a lot of “liquid courage” during those years.
Getting into the local scene enhanced my political consciousness, not because the bands themselves were concerned with political issues (most of them weren’t), but because I could see how they had formed a commu- nity based on creative work and participation. It wasn’t a dogmatic scene of the sort advocated in the pages of Maximumrocknroll, and therefore a great variety of musical styles and influences could be thrown together without apology. And so I began to see the form of democratic cultural production as more significant than the content of any particular politi- cal protest or “message.” This understanding of “punk” as a method of production rather than a specific style or sound opened up whole vistas of possibility and informed my belated musical education. Maybe I can explain it this way: Drive Like Jehu led me back to Fugazi and then even further back to Wire and then forward to the Minutemen and Hiisker Dii and then back again to the Gang of Four and Television. See, I told you my path to punk was ass-backwards.
While the Casbah and other local nightclubs were becoming a second home for me, I was still suffering from quite a bit of intellectual homeless- ness on campus. I was getting a lot more out of the graduate courses I was taking in other departments, so I stopped enrolling in sociology seminars after completing my minimum amount of required coursework and came very close to dropping out of the program. I took a position as a teach- ing assistant in an interdisciplinary freshman-level writing course, where the levels of overwork were legendary. Before long I had become heavily involved with the effort to unionize the academic student employees at the University of California and would be elected to serve on the strike committee as we planned a number of strategies for work stoppage. This took me further out of the bounds of the Sociology department, as my social circle was now mainly composed of humanities students who were involved with me in organizing the T-A. union. Intellectually, however, I never embraced the kind of cultural studies that is practiced in the hu- manities, where meaning is mainly located in the “text” and acts of resis- tance are conceived as symbolic matters of reading and style. I was still fundamentally concerned with social process, and the Marxist in me still sought to link culture back to social structure. My experiences in the music scene redoubled these convictions: resistance was a matter of how people organized their community and engaged in creative work, not what people wore, how they cut their hair, or what they sang about in their lyrics.
My intellectual homelessness was glaringly evident and became a huge liability when I went on the job market for the first time in the
ON BECOMING A PUNK ROCK SOCIOLOGIST 63
fall of 1999. It seems that what transpired in my graduate program was something like a microcosm of what was happening in American sociol- ogy in general. There has been a great expansion of interest and research in culture among American sociologists since the 1980s, but these cul- tural sociologists have taken great pains to distinguish and insulate them- selves from the broader field of cultural studies. The studies of popular culture and media, much less popular music, are very few and far be- tween. American cultural sociology is significantly more conventional, eager to be accepted within the mainstream of the discipline, and rarely engaged with questions of power and resistance. Don’t take my word for it, listen to what one of the leading proponents has to say in its favor: “American cultural sociology is conservative rather than revolutionary in its academic program, unlike the British cultural studies model which has attempted to transgress disciplinary boundaries and create a com- pletely new academic and discursive field.”’
No matter what kind of theoretical and methodological spin I try to put on it, my work reeks of cultural studies simply because it is has the word punk attached to it. I sent out over 100 job applications during my first 3 years on the market without landing a single on-campus interview. I nearly gave up on the idea of an academic career on several occasions, but a lack of other marketable skills and job experience made me feel trapped, and I still had a deep intellectual passion, not necessarily for sociology but for understanding social processes and contributing to so- cial change. Fortunately I was able to hang on as an adjunct instructor of sociology at UC San Diego, as my courses on popular culture and youth attracted very high student enrollments; I taught a total of nearly 1,000 students during my final year there in 2001-02.
As my contract with UC San Diego and a long-term romantic rela- tionship both came to an end at virtually the same time, I found myself living with my mother and collecting unemployment in late 2002. I was ready to give up on academia once and for all when I miraculously got a temporary position at the University of Kansas that began in the Spring 2003 semester and lasted through the 2003-04 school year. I sent out another heap of job applications but still couldn’t land a satisfactory tenure-track position, so I accepted another temporary appointment at Colgate University for 2004-05.
In 2005 I finally landed a tenure-track position at Florida Atlantic University. It’s not a prestigious school by any means, but it’s a good place for a punk like me: lots of older, “non-traditional” and working- class students, many of whom have roots in the Caribbean. Securing a permanent academic home has afforded me the time to finally finish
64 PUNKADEMICS
turning my dissertation into a book titled Sells Like Teen Spirit: Music, Youth Culture, and Social Crisis which was published by New York Uni- versity Press in 2009. Meanwhile, American sociology continues to as- pire to the status of a science along the lines of economics and political science while attempting to avoid the stigma of the humanities conferred by cultural studies, and so there is no reason to expect that the study of punk or any other form of music will be moving into the center of the discipline any time soon. But somehow this feels like the appropriate place for a punk rock sociologist: screaming from the margins, denounc- ing the mainstream, and maybe — just maybe — developing the new ideas that are destined to shake up the establishment.
NOTES 1 Phillip Smith, Zhe New American Cultural Sociology (Cambridge: Cam-
bridge University Press, 1998), p. 9.
CURRY MALOTT
FINDING BALANCE IN THE ACADEMY
FINISHING MY PHD in 2004 took me to Brooklyn College/CUNY where I took what they call a Substitute Line, which is a full time position, but without the institutional security of a tenure-track job. You are basically hired on a semester-by-semester basis. Your standing is probationary. I did not transition into professor life very well. Living a few blocks from campus, I remained (and still do) a hardcore punk rock skateboarder, but without any strategic room for adaptability. I was still suffering de- moralization from having a social movement I helped start in Southern New Mexico infiltrated and destroyed.! I was never really accepted by the majority of faculty as legitimate or serious — I was too resistant to accept university culture. However, my classes were outstanding at Brooklyn College, which has left me a legacy there. I was also active in the union where I worked with students doing punk rock street theatre protesting contract disputes.
After leaving Brooklyn College as a result of being pushed out, I went to D’Youville College in Buffalo, New York where I learned to find bal- ance and develop the ability to focus, intensely, on developing my critical pedagogy through becoming a better writer/researcher/scholar and criti- cal educator.’ For me, this has included, among other things, learning to identify where power resides, understanding how it operates, and then devising methods of challenging if for a more democratic, less-oppressive future through the development of a community of activist scholars. In short, revitalizing my social movement background in the context of academia. Enduring the cold winters in Buffalo, NY in a small studio apartment, in an old downtown building, with no car, and living on a low wage working at a very humble institution with very little money, taught me humility. Outside of Buffalo, very few academics have ever even heard of D’youville College. That does not necessarily make one feel
66 PUNKADEMICS
special or important in the world of academia. Raised in the competitive fervor of U.S. dominant society, it is most difficult not to succumb to its pressures. That is, while punk rock strives to reject and live outside of dominant society, it is difficult not to be influenced by its hierarchical values of prestige. At the same time, however, I know that it is good for critical pedagogy to have critical pedagogues at well-respected universi- ties. If leading critical intellectuals did not hold important positions at the most well-respected institutions, it would be much easier to discredit the Left.
Despite these contradictory motivations, my epistemological and on- tological punk rock desire to stay out of reach of cooptation has led me to become a very effective, and very critical classroom teacher and activist scholar. When I am teaching or observing student teachers I no longer wear my punk uniform; I traded it in for a more intense and critical pedagogy and content. This has made me more acceptable, on an insti- tutional level, and more effective at the student level. By no means do I intend this to be taken as a prescription. It is working for me, a white male from working class southern Ohio, but that does not mean it is the answer for others. It was not the answer for me five years ago and it may not be the answer for me five or ten years down the road. Currently, I am working at West Chester University as an Assistant Professor and am making great personal gains in honing more practice and skill. To make these determinations and have this consciousness, however, I must stay open to the late critical pedagogue Joe L. Kincheloe’s insight that:
“In their search for ways to produce democratic and evoca- tive knowledges, critical constructivists become detectives of new ways of seeing and constructing the world.”?
NOTES
1 See Curry Malott, Policy and Research in Education: A Critical Pedagogy for Educational Leadership (New York: Peter Lang, 2010).
2 Curry Malott, “Schooling in an Era of Corporate Dominance: Marxism Against Burning Tires,” Journal for Critical Education Policy Studies, Vol. 4, No.1 (2006).
3 Joe Kincheloe, Critical Constructivism Primer, (New York: Peter Lang, 2005), p. 4.
WALEED RASHIDI
PUNK ROCK DOCS: A QUALITATIVE STUDY'
“WOULD YOU STOP WORRYING ABOUT THE PUNKS? THEY'RE JUST A BUNCH OF KIDS WITH GROWING PAINS. THEY'LL PROBABLY BE DOCTORS AND LAWYERS SOMEDAY.”
- FROM THE TELEVISION PROGRAM CHIPS
OVERVIEW THIS RESEARCH INVESTIGATES a group of punk rock musicians with doctoral-level education via a series of in-depth interviews. The study aims to develop a stronger understanding of punk rock musicians’ mo- tivations, justifications, philosophies and conclusions regarding the way they balance a punk rock lifestyle and persona with careers in aca- demic and/or highly intellectual professions (e.g. medical, legal, scien- tific). Though such highly educated punk musicians are a minor subset of the punk genre’s total population, this segment contradicts many of the negative perceptions about punk rock as well as the messages relayed by mainstream media and culture that have often stereotyped punk rockers as uneducated, antisocial, delinquent, or violent.? Such balancing acts and contradictions serve as the study’s point of entry.
EXCLUSIONARY /INCLUSIONARY
FACTORS
The primary criteria for the study’s participants include being musi- cians in the punk rock music scene and having been students in a doctoral
68 PUNKADEMICS
program. Musicians may be self-described as punk rock, or may hail from an ancillary scene that is related to punk rock (e.g., emo, hardcore). The selected participants must have performed in a touring band in the Ameri- can punk scene for a minimum of two years and have at least one domesti- cally distributed, commercially-available album recording to their credit. These minimum requirements formed a participant population that had strong insight into the commercial operations and background of the U.S. punk rock scene. Participants must also have doctoral degrees, though an experienced punk rock musician whose status is A.B.D. (all but disserta- tion) also qualified as a participant for this study.
RESULTS
A number of in-depth interviews were conducted in the winter and spring of 2008. The responses from the participant population were tran- scribed and analyzed. Each response was then parsed into sections that were subsequently coded into categories that included: Upbringing, Cur- rent Occupation, Education, Punk Ideology/Philosophy, Recurring Words, Time Management, Negotiation of Identity, Personality, and Intellectual- ism in Punk Rock. Coded responses in each category were then further subcategorized into ‘aspects’ that are meant to offer more exacting detail about what constitutes the broader categories themselves. Interview ex- cerpts are presented here for a more transparent understanding of the data that led to the formulation of each category.
The first category, Upbringing, includes the aspects parents’ education, motivation, socio-economic status, and punk attraction. In regard to parents education, most participants hailed from a background that included at least one parent with an advanced degree and had been (or currently is) employed in a highly regarded profession, such as university professor, at- torney, and engineer. One participant detailed his parents’ background, “Both of my parents were college professors. My mom taught at Michi- gan State University and my dad taught at University of Michigan. Both taught sociology and both were PhDs.” Another participant, a psychologist who specializes in adolescents, also noted his parents’ educational creden- tials, including the fact that he and his mother have similar educational backgrounds: “My mom has her master’s degree in child psychology, ironi- cally enough, and my dad has his doctorate in chemical engineering.”
In the next aspect, motivation, it was found that participants were either self-motivated to pursue higher education and advanced degrees, or that they were encouraged by parents or other authority figures. With respect to self-motivation, one participant, who had entered a history
PUNK ROCK DOCS 69
graduate program stated, “So when I went back to [graduate school], you know, I was like, “Well, I had done the English thing, I had done the philosophy thing, I don’t know nearly enough about history.’ And in part it was because I started reading history on my own shortly after I gradu- ated, when I moved to San Francisco with the band.” Two participants said that career paths and educational pursuits were established at a very young age. One stated, “I always had aspirations to do something profes- sional. I was going to become a doctor since I was seven years old. That's kind of been my whole push.” Another provided a similar answer, even in reference to the timeframe, “I always knew I wanted to be a lawyer, like from the time I was five or six. I just always knew. It just, my brain was wired that way. You know, a lot of kids, they want to be this, they want to be that, but I pretty much knew.” Other responses suggest the role of outside influences in participants’ decisions to pursue professions that required advanced degrees. One notes, “It was always expected that I would go to college, even though I started [music] when I was 15.” An- other participant said, “In the area that I was raised, college was like 13" grade. It’s just [...] what you did.” Furthermore, one participant had not actually thought about completing his undergraduate education until motivated by a guidance counselor:
I was walking through the halls of community college, and I was a straight ‘A’ student there. And the guidance counselor, who I didnt really know, sort of saw me in the hall and he said, ‘Hey, you know, what are you going to do when youre done this spring?’ And I hadn’t given it any thought, so I talked to him a little bit about it just informally in the hall, and he said, “Well, you know, these colleges have some great scholarship programs.’
In discussing the socio-economic status aspect of the participants’ up- bringings, almost all had stated that they were from middle-to-upper class households. Class was mentioned in a few interviews, including one participant, who stated, “You know [...] I went to high school in an upper middle-class suburban community. You know, one of those high schools that’s allegedly, you know, one of the top few in the state, blah blah blah.” Another participant said, “And I don’t come from a very wealthy family at all, you know, probably very solidly middle-class family.” Other ways of determining socio-economic status could be as- certained from the occupations of the respondents’ parents, including a particularly revealing statement from this participant, “This is weird
70 PUNKADEMICS
because this is going to sound like, and I don’t mean this in, like, a bragging way, but just because I know you're looking for these common denominators or not in background — they were very high up, especially my father, in state government.”
Punk attraction is also a particularly noteworthy aspect to the par- ticipants’ upbringing, in that many were attracted to punk rock music and the punk lifestyle at an early age — mostly before they enrolled in college — and some found that it helped shape their decision-making at later junctures in life. As adolescents, some noted that alienation was cause for their gravitation towards the punk aesthetic. One participant first discovered punk rock around the ages of 15-16, using a metaphor to explain his attraction, “Well, I was alienated. And, you know, it was like all of a sudden, it was like I was wandering around in another country where I didn’t speak the language, and then I met somebody who spoke my language. And fell in love.” Such alienation, he continues, stems from the lack of interest in athletics, a particularly powerful determinant in adolescent male social circles:
If youre a man in this society, and you suck at sports [...] ages 7 to 14 are [a] pretty outright hostile [...] period in which to live...Your ‘malehood, if there’s such a word, is defined essentially by, you know, if not excellence in sports, at least competence. Sort of not having that was a pretty ter- rifying experience for me...I think that’s an extreme experi- ence with alienation. And then like, to learn about politics and the, you know, Reagan government and the, you know, the Cold War and McCarthyism and all that shit. In the town I lived in, I was just like, “God. This place is a night- mare’...So, I was pissed and alienated and like, punk just spoke to it so directly and in such a visceral way. My first show was Reagan Youth and, you know, it was exactly about everything I was pissed about.
Others echoed such sentiment, particularly in the formation of an identity:
I was a teenager and wanted to create an identity, and the punk scene was in its infancy here in L.A., so it was a very exciting time to be an L.A. punk...as a teenager, you dont really understand what youre doing. You just feel good, when you feel like youre a part of something. It’s a social
PUNK ROCK DOCS va)
connection, it’s something, and if that social group can be a unique group, you can tell youre different from others. That gave me even greater satisfaction, knowing that it was some- thing unique. And by unique, I realize that we didn’t invent anything. But you sure feel unique when youre a minority in and amongst the kind of culture that it was back then.
Lastly, responses also included the fact that punk rock was decidedly easier to play than other rock music derivations — particularly during the time period of many of the participants’ introduction to the genre, and that such simplistic empowerment was crucial in the development of their musical careers. According to one participant, “Punk was the antithesis of progressive rock. You didn’t have to be classically trained to play punk. And I think that was very attractive, that we could actually be in the band.” Another stated, “It was like, you listen to the Ramones first record, like ‘Beat On The Brat’ [...] and even as an 11- or 12-year-old, youre listening to this, going, [...] “Wow, I could do that too. That seems like something I could do.”
The second category, Current Occupation, yielded the aspects author- ity, self-employment/autonomy, punk-professional interrelations, and punk values in occupation. The first aspect, authority, suggested that nearly all of the participants were employed in influential positions within their respective fields, whether over others in their occupation, or in the case of professors, an influence in the classroom with students and colleagues. One participant, who holds a rank in the U.K. academic system equiva- lent to a U.S. Assistant Professor, is also charged with running his own academic research group, and is thus an authority on two levels:
So, yeah, my basic job is to write grants, get money and then hire people. And right now I’ve got about eight people working for me. So I’ve got three post-doctoral fellows, a couple Ph.D. students and an M.Sc. student, a master’s student, and a technician and visiting scientists, so that’s kind of [...] how it works...mainly doing research and then you do some teaching.
Another participant, a physician, is deputized with overseeing his im- mediate hospital staff as well as other aspects of emergency care, “’m actually not only an emergency physician there, but I’m also the EMS medical director, so I’m in charge of the medical direction for the emer- gency medical systems, which includes the paramedics and pre-hospital
72 PUNKADEMICS
care that goes out to the patients. It’s four different providers out there picking up the patients.”
Some participants found their autonomous occupational positions to be not only conducive to their schedules — especially for those who are currently performing and touring musicians — but also a reflection of their punk rock philosophy, i.e. being independent from outside constraints. In regard to a prevailing do-it-yourself culture at his current occupation, one participant noted, “I think it was easy for me to embrace this kind of research lifestyle, because of the fact that I always felt like, when we were doing our music, that we had to put in all this effort to make it happen. We had to organize our T-shirts, we had to organize our [merchandise] and our music, and write the songs, and you wore a lot of different hats. And I feel like that same sort of spirit is also in my research career, so I think that aspect of it does translate over.” Another participant, a psychologist with his own private practice, stated that his choice for se/femployment was, in itself, punk rock, “Yeah, being self-employed is very punk, and it’s some- thing that I always kind of fantasized about when I was younger.”
Within their present occupations, there was a distinct divide between whether the participants accepted an infusion of their pre-established punk values and/or background into their professional settings, or whether they purposefully tried to sever these ties once they entered their respective pro- fessions. Some had elected to keep aspects of their musical careers out of the workplace, as evidenced by this participant’s response, “You know, in a lot of ways, I keep my band life very separate from my [professional] career life, which is just a boundary that ’'m comfortable with.” Another partici- pant, who is employed as a science lecturer at a university, added, “No, ’m actually very careful not to infuse values into science. It’s really important. And it’s not a soapbox up there.” To the contrary, other participants spoke of how their punk background and history had merged with their profes- sional pursuits, including another university science professor, “I kind of got that training, that life training, if you will, from being in these sorts of bands, you know, to think creatively, to solve problems that are kind of outside the box sort of thinking, if you will [...]”
Another aspect, punk values in occupation, emerged after partici- pants acknowledged that their interpretation of the punk value system had indeed been incorporated within their professional careers. One of these values includes the idea of bucking stereotypes, as detailed by this participant:
It’s a matter of you standing for...I mean, hell, I’m a 6-foot- 5 black guy with dreadlocks who's a physician. People have
PUNK ROCK DOCS 73
to make assumptions when they see you. I’m like bucking their assumptions right there. When I walk right into the room, it’s like, “You don’t look like a doctor.’ My first words out of my mouth are, ‘What does a doctor look like?’ I mean, right there, it’s affronting their whole belief system and showing them that there’s another way to be.
Another participant, an adolescent psychologist, spoke of a similar way in which punk values affect his work, “It informs my career in that I want to challenge, especially with boys...I want to offer an alternative construction of masculinity.”
The third category presented, Education, includes the aspects school selection and success compulsion. In regard to school selection, many sought undergraduate and graduate programs that were fitting for their majors and eventual career goals, while others just had a generally positive over- all feeling about the school. Most notably, some participants used prox- imity to punk scenes and bandmates as factors in choosing schools and respective programs. One participant noted, “I was like, ‘fuck it, Pll go to U of I’ My best friend was going there, you know, I was super involved [at] that point in the [city, state] punk rock scene.” Another stated, “I ultimately went to [...] Washington University at St. Louis, which is also very strong in biology and biomedical sciences, too. Part of my deci- sion again there, was proximity to Lafayette. Obviously St. Louis is only about a four or five hour drive from Lafayette, versus being on the West Coast. But I could still kind of do music a bit, as much as I could with the guys and that sort of thing.” One participant, however, selected his graduate program due to the fact that his school had rebelled against another program with which it was once associated, “It also had a very kind of ‘punk’ tradition that I found appealing.”
The second aspect of the Education category is success compulsion. This refers to the way participants felt challenged or compelled to succeed in both their musical and academic endeavors. One participant explained, “It's one of those things where you think of a manifest destiny, where you go, ‘Hey, I’m thinking of this, I want to do this. I am going to do it.’ It’s like that book The Secret, or whatever. It is just a matter of something I wanted to do. And it’s what always interested me. And I attained that goal.” Some participants noted the influence of other punk rockers that attained doctorates, even referencing them by name during the course of our interviews. For example, the participant quoted above also stated, “When I heard about the guy from [punk band name] or when you hear about [other punk rocker with doctorate], and you go, “Those are the
74 PUNKADEMICS
guys that I idolize and they’re doing something, it’s like, “Whoa, what the hell? I could do that too.’ That’s why I had a kinship with this stuff”
Another category that had surfaced is Punk Ideology/Philosophy. This is a core category due to the fact that it is considered to be very personal, highly subjective and interpretive, given that punk rock itself does not have clearly demarcated boundaries of what it is considered ‘acceptable’ for the genre, either musically or philosophically. However, after interviewing the participants, I discovered that nearly all responses could be categorized and coded into one of three aspects: questioning, ethical foundations, and com- munity. Questioning was mentioned in the context of challenging the status quo and/or being intellectually provocative. Some of the viewpoints shared around questioning included one from this participant:
The whole punk rock thing is questioning authority..-youre told one thing, and yourre like, “What the hell, that doesn’t make any sense.’ And you investigate and you go, ‘Really. It doesn’t make any sense!’ And that’s something that I think is a punk rock sentiment..-you question things that are actu- ally told to you...And that, in my opinion, might be one of the reasons why you find a lot of academics that come out of punk rock because of a questioning attitude. ..and thirst to gain more knowledge about a topic.
Another participant said, “Being punk, I think, means always ques- tioning and never settling. Always moving and always progressing. It means challenging the status quo, whether it’s in the world at large or within the punk scene.” This participant offered his views on questioning as it relates to both his punk rock philosophy and his academic study of philosophy, “I like to think at some level, the notion of questioning the world around me, and accepting the fact that you don’t have to take things as they're given to you, you don’t have to accept the standard order of things, I think that’s partially what I was looking for in phi- losophy, too.” Furthermore, one participant was able to relay the idea of questioning as a punk rock philosophy within his occupation as a scien- tist/academic: “It basically means that you're provocative, but not in a violent way. You make people ask questions. You make them wonder... The only way to search, the only way science really works is if you can completely dismantle the framework of science by asking the questions that haven't been asked before. And the only way you can do that is by provoking people who are content with the way that this framework is already erected.”
PUNK ROCK DOCS 75
Other punk rock musicians described an ethical foundation on which they based their punk philosophy, which was partly tied to ethical busi- ness practices. One participant noted, “I think it has a lot to do with how you conduct your business in terms of touring and being fair to other bands, and uh, being fair all around.” Another participant stated, “T definitely define it as a community and an ethic and an approach, [but] an approach to what is still, essentially, in some ways, a business. As opposed to a certain music scene.” In addition to these responses, some participants also expressed resistance towards mass marketing of the punk sound and likeness. The ethical foundation of punk rock also extended into aspects of community and the social organization of punk. One participant noted:
I don’t even know if it’s a punk ideal anymore, but when it got started punk was very tolerant; very much about accepting people for who they were. It quickly became a fashion culture, so there’s a lot of judgment of who wore certain clothes, versus other clothes. That didn’t interest me at all, that part of it. The part I liked is that if you were a misfit, you were welcomed in the club. You were welcomed to come and be a part of this community. And that was very attractive to me.
In understanding how the participants have been able to parse the time between their professional obligations and their musical activities, I found it necessary to include a category labeled Time Management. The aspects of Time Management include time balance (between schooling/ bands), current time negotiation, and difficulties in time management. The balance of performing in a punk band and being engaged in academia was discussed throughout the interviews, with several taking time off of school for their punk band-related activities (mainly touring and record- ing), as noted by this participant, “I moved home to Jersey, moved in with my folks, got like a social work job and started looking into grad school and started a band. And then I did that for two years before I went back to school. And my doctorate was a five-year program, but I took a year off in the middle of it to tour.”
Two other participants recounted their decisions to put school on hold for their musical endeavors. One stated:
Just at that moment, the first [participant’s band] record was doing really well. We had broken up after the first tour in ‘90 and basically, it was a choice of, ‘Do I stay in New
76
PUNKADEMICS
York and continue in academia, or do I do the band thing?’ I decided, ‘’m going to do the band, because I could always come back to school.’ And so that was always in the back of my mind. And so, eventually, when the band broke up in “96, I started going back.
Another said, “We decided to [...] try to do it full-time for a while.
And that’s kind of when the whole [participant’s band] ‘thing’ happened for us. So we took a break there from the academic thing for a few years, and then ultimately, after two years, decided to eventually get back to it.” However, others performed in bands while concurrently enrolled in their academic programs, whether during vacations or throughout the school
year. One participant, who was touring in her band while simultaneously attending law school, recalled her experience:
First semester of law school, [participant’s band] was still a growing concern and you know, we did like a week-and-a- half tour with [another band], which happened to be their last tour. But I had class every day. So we would literally, like, drive to Columbus, play a show with them, drive back overnight so [participant’s name] can go to class. Drive back to Cleveland. We were doing a tour, but making it back to Chicago every day in between and that sucked.
Another participant recalls his experience with his band while at-
tending medical school, and how his prioritization ultimately led to the
demise of his band:
Well, things had to be neglected. But things that were never neglected were school. That was the priority. That was the thing. That was one of the reasons why the band broke up, initially, because I had to start residency during one of our last tours. So, [the] tour was going to go on, but I had to start residency, so I was like, ‘Guys, I’ve gotta go. That’s
it.’ I had to leave in the middle of a tour because I had to start residency. What was I going to do? Tell the residency program, “Hey, you know what, one of your residents isn’t going to be there, because I’m in a band right now tour- ing, and I can’t make it in. Can you guys just have my calls covered?’ No, it wasn’t going to go that way. My priority number one was being a physician.
PUNK ROCK DOCS 77
Current time negotiation relates to the principles of maintaining a schedule that is both conducive to performing in a punk band and work- ing as a professional. This aspect includes employment scheduling, and the consideration of family members and spouses. Since many partici- pants are in positions of seniority at their respective workplaces, some found it easy to create and maintain time schedules that would allow for recording, touring, and band-related engagements. One participant is employed in academia as a lecturer at a university during specific quar- ters; his schedule is such that he is able to take time off from academia to tour and record. In fact, he said that his band is where he generates a majority of his income, which is not the case for nearly all the other par- ticipants in this study, who have to generate their primary income from their non punk-related occupations. However, there are times — particu- larly in rehearsals for upcoming events or during recording sessions — where an overlap of functions is possible for this particular participant, as explained here:
The days start early, and they end late. But, you know, [...] we'll spend our days here on campus, meeting with students and lecturing. And then I head out of here by 4 or 5 p.m., and for instance, tonight, we'll be at the rehearsal studio
at 7:30 until probably 11:30. And some years — like last year — after lecture, ’d zoom into Hollywood and we would be recording a new album. I was there from 6 p.m. until midnight every day.
Another participant, a private practitioner, explained that his balance between his professional occupation and musical endeavors is manage- able because he is selfemployed, and can therefore work as little or as much as he chooses. This participant said that he works four days a week, and is easily able to perform a string of Friday-Saturday-Sunday shows. He often does not work mornings and therefore has time to make it home by the start of a Monday workday:
Like most people have to come in after school or after work, so I’m generally seeing people between 1 in the afternoon and 10 at night. So [...] all the kinds of mechanics of being in a band are much more doable. I can go to practice until midnight, I can go to rehearsal until midnight, and then sleep in. I can play Baltimore, D.C. and Richmond in the same weekend, and still not miss any work. And I could,
78 PUNKADEMICS
you know, unlike the average working American, I can take six weeks off a year, as long as it’s spread out, to tour.
Because all of the participants interviewed were older than 30, many had spouses and children to factor into their time scheduling. This some- times created additional complexity and difficulty, as explained by this participant:
“I mean, sometimes no thought goes into it at all, and sometimes I’m extremely stressed out. It’s mostly because I’m married, and I don’t want my wife to be abandoned. I don’t want her to be a music widow. And I’m real sensitive to, you know, being available for her, and I’m [...] often anxious about whether I’m pushing the limits a little bit, in terms of how much time I’m away. So it’s not so much tak- ing the time and making the time, it’s anxiety about making the time. That’s what actually wears on me. I don’t want
to jeopardize my relationship, nor do I want to make her unhappy. So, that’s the hardest part.”
Another participant mentioned that he had to receive his spouse’s bless- ing: “In my situation, where ’'m married and I have a baby, you have to have a very supportive spouse.” Another participant echoed a similar senti- ment, “I have a very supportive family that allows me to do these sorts of things...that makes it easy.” In addition to spouses and family consider- ations, one participant also spoke of the changes in financial responsibility that were linked to his participation in a punk band: “It’s different when youre in your 20s, you're 21, 22, and you live in a house with a bunch of other guys, and you know, maybe you pay a $100 or $150 a month in rent...[but] I’m 35, and I’m married and I have a daughter, and three dogs, and a mortgage and a business and everything like that, it just makes it more difficult to leave for significant periods of time.”
Negotiating Identity is a category that relates to how the participants view themselves in a punk rock context, how they believe they are per- ceived by others for their punk rock and educational backgrounds, and which stereotypes and assumptions are made about them because of their backgrounds. The category also discusses how the participants believe their lives have been affected because they are punk rock musicians who have climbed the ranks of higher academia and are now in professional employment positions. A number of aspects emerged from this particu- lar category, including fan perception, professional colleague perception,
PUNK ROCK DOCS 79
lifestyle, prestige, stereotypes and assumptions, and punk musician. Regard- ing fan perception, the participants often spoke about what they believed their fans and supporters of their musical endeavors thought of their educational and professional pursuits, either from information they re- ceived directly from fans, or based on inferences. For the most part, par- ticipants felt that their fans were largely accepting of the fact they had advanced degrees and worked in professional settings. One mentioned that a fan had actually been inspired to pursue higher academics based on the fact that he had done so:
Some girl told me once, she emailed me, and said, she went into medicine because of me, which is kind of cool.” Another participant also had “direct evidence” about inspiring fans to engage in such professional pursuits based on his profession, “A lot of fans write to me, and say, ‘I wouldn't have gone to college if it wasn’t for [participant's band name]’ and ‘I’m becoming a biologist because of your lyrics.’ So I mean, I have some pretty direct evidence that some students are affected by it.
However, another participant felt that although she was accepted by her fans, she wasn’t always completely in step with her fellow punk rock musicians because of her professional background, “But I definitely think other musicians-promoters were always cool with it, and writers were always very into it — but you know, I felt sometimes like it set me apart from other musicians. Like I didn’t totally fit in because there was this other side of me, always.”
The aspect professional colleague perception compartmentalized reac- tions that the participants received from their colleagues in their profes- sional settings, when their punk rock background and history is revealed. Many stated that their co-workers were often apathetic about the partici- pants’ punk backgrounds, as this professor noted: “Well, academics, as you know, are pretty much out of touch. So they don’t really care. They think it’s interesting, you know, and they’re happy that somebody can have another career other than academia. They don’t really take it very seriously.” However, some stated that their dual-career became notewor- thy amongst their peers. Two participants specifically mentioned their co-workers discovering YouTube videos of their musical endeavors and sharing them in their workplace: “I think that most find it amusing. You know, I mean [...] I haven’t heard anything negative there, I think most people just think it’s kind of cool that I did that sort of thing.” Another
80 PUNKADEMICS
added, “My firm, for the most part, they know my story, they know where I come from [...] they probably seek that out in me more than | want to show them. Like there are partners who love it, and everybody they introduce me to, they’re like, “This is [participant’s name]. She was in a band.’ And I'm like, “Okay, ’'m a lawyer. Can we just drop it?” And for one participant, mentioning his punk background actually triggered like-minded responses from his colleagues who were also interested in punk music, “Somebody will then start mentioning their little forays into punk rock. ‘T used to listen to such and such’ and ‘Yeah man, oh, you like the New York Dolls?”
Prestige is another aspect of identity negotiation, and most partici- pants seemed to enjoy the placement in society that their current occupa- tion has afforded them. However, one participant is uncomfortable with the punk scene’s identification of his doctoral status, “...That’s kind of annoying, but like, I really think it creates an artificial distance. I’m not actually that comfortable with it, but ’m not going to yell at people for calling me that either.” The same participant suggested that punk rock- ers attaining these positions and degrees allows for the genre to be given more credence in society: “I think some people are like, “Wow...okay.’ I think it maybe helps some people take punk a little more seriously [...] and music a little more seriously...maybe it shows people the possibil- ity of what you can do with your life. That you could have a grown-up, straight job and still, like, yell about the government, jump in the pit and write protest songs and still be furious and have your eyes open.”
A key aspect of identity negotiation is stereotypes and assumptions that are made about both punk rockers and those who engage in higher aca- demia. As stated earlier, one participant — a physician — shatters people's assumptions about what a physician should look like. Furthermore, he adds, “And so, a part of me wearing dreadlocks, and walking around is kind of a total ‘fuck you’ to a person’s mindset, to say, ‘Hey, you know what, you're looking at me, and you don’t even know anything about me.”” Some have chosen to neither buck nor embrace the stereotypes on either end of the spectrum, and still other participants felt like they were not entirely accepted within either ‘realm,’ as noted by this participant, “T feel like I'm a perpetual seventh grader, in that, like, ] maybe will never feel like I fully fit in anywhere. I was kind of freaking out a few months ago, and I was like, ‘Oh my god, youre 31, you could not be doing this.”” Another participant expressed a similar view, “I think, to some degree, that I’ve always kind of felt, not like an outsider, but I just don't feel like I’m the standard of either one [...] a little too academic for your standard punk, and probably a little too punk rock for your standard academic.”
PUNK ROCK DOCS 81
The last aspect of identity negotiation is that of the punk musician. While for some participants, playing punk rock music was just a hobby (and for some it was their former career/former second career), other participants identified punk rock as a secondary career. And for one participant, per- forming punk rock was a current, main source of income, even though he concurrently held a professional position in higher academia.
The merging of Jntellectualism in Punk Rock is a category that emerged with a number of wide-ranging responses from the participant popula- tion. Aspects of this category include the art form, articulated ideals and ethics, subgroup dependency, and punk rock in academia. Viewed as the art form, some believed that punk rock was inherently intellectual, as stated by this participant, “Well, punk is an art form, and [...] art is an intel- lectual movement, so yes, absolutely.” Another participant concurred, though from a slightly different position, “I would have to say from the standpoint of it being an intellectual art form [...] it’s an acquired taste. Maybe it’s for the person that has an eclectic set of values to [interpret] things, versus, ‘Feed it to me on a big spoon because it’s sugary sweet and I like it, and I don’t care who actually is behind it, it’s all good for me.’ That’s the general masses.” Many participants noted that punk rock’s in- tellect was best displayed in musicians’ ability to articulate ideals and ethics. One participant offered this reasoning: “If it’s protest music, it should be a place for intelligent discourse [about] what youre protesting, and why. I think the idea that punk is somehow anti-intellectual is also in some ways antithetical to its core tenets. You know what I mean? It’s like, how do you do critique if you’re not coming from, like, an intellectual perspective?” An additional position was highlighted by a participant who found punk rock’s intellectual foundations to be more substantive than those evident in the standard rock genre, “I think that there is more room in punk rock to be intellectual, because I think, to some degree, it’s very accepted within the genre to be, to have, political views; to have kind of deep thoughts on things, which maybe, in your standard rock environment, wouldn't be as appreciated.”
Despite these shared perspectives, the responses of some participants reveal a certain level of subgroup dependency which, in this scenario, means that intellectual discourse within punk rock was not universal and that only particular subgroups — perhaps divided by region or by indi- vidual factions — were thought to maintain an intellectual climate. For instance, one participant noted, “At this point, punk rock encompasses a broad spectrum of music styles and different bands and different people. And you know, just like society itself, there’s a subgroup of that section that’s not going to be intellectual, and there’s a subgroup that will be.
82 PUNKADEMICS
And you know, you just gotta find the people you want to talk to.” A supporting example is offered by a different participant:
I think it so depends on the scene, and the town, and the bands. I think there are people in punk rock that are im- mensely intellectual. And those are probably the people I’ve gravitated towards over the years in the sense that they're part of the punk rock community; there is an ethic or ideal behind it. There is this philosophy that’s not accidental, that’s very thought through and articulated in their heads. And there are tons of [other] people who are just like, ‘It’s rebellion! Fuck this and fuck [that].’
Furthermore, some participants noted that the anarchist tradition in punk rock — a subgroup in itself — had an intellectual bend, as articulated by one response, “The /Sex/ Pistols use of anarchy was just like, posturing. But Cvass and the anarchists [...] everything that grew out of that, it was very intellectual. It was connected to the intellectual tradition of anarchism and situationism and I think those are pretty intellectual movements.”
The final aspect of this category, punk rock in academia, sought to develop answers from participants based on their thoughts of whether they could see punk rock merging with academia in any way. One par- ticipant stated that an over-analysis of punk rock at an academic level could “sterilize” it:
Yd hate to see it, like, too overly subjected to analysis, because I hate the idea of people who have no first-hand knowledge of it, like bandying about terms in [...] a teacher’s lounge somewhere in a university. I mean, I guess they can if they want. But I don’t know how much mean- ing it has if they haven't lived it some way. But I guess it’s the same way that an anthropologist looks at the !Kung in the Kalahari, you know.. intellectual inquiry is distancing in a lot of ways. Just like, you know, intellectualization as
a defense mechanism distances us from our emotions and other people, I think that an over-application of intellectual inquiry, or of intellectual methodology, to the punk subcul- ture can kind of sterilize it.
The infusion of punk’s ideology into academia, on the other hand, was found to be acceptable and feasible to most participants, notably as a
PUNK ROCK DOCS 83
vehicle to expand critical thinking and its inherent appeal to college-aged students. Still, one participant expressed concern with punk’s ability to merge with academia by stating, “I think there’s not enough organization in punk rock. You know, it’s just too disorganized.”
REVIEWING THE DATA
The data presented several key findings. First, the idea that punk rockers are not only attracted to higher academia, but actually enter and succeed in this domain, is in line with the shift in stereotype of the tra- ditional academic. The now-cliché image of “ivory towers” being solely occupied by “bookworms” is belied by the presence of an increasingly more diverse population of graduate students, professors, researchers, and the like. This includes the group of punk musicians interviewed for this study, whose backgrounds are unlike most career academicians. Though not all the participants were employed in academia after attend- ing graduate school, the fact that they were engaged in higher academia as students contributes to the changing profile of both punk rock and academia itself. Findings also reflected a general acceptance of punk rockers as intellectuals, from both fans and colleagues alike, which helps to support this assertion. The disappearing stereotype of the uneducated, unruly punk rocker is partly a function of punks’ involvement in higher academia and a variety of professional endeavors.
Second, because many of the participants retained their punk phi- losophies, particularly via grassroots/DIY ethics and an independent out- look, most of the participants were doubly motivated to succeed, not just in academia but also in their musical careers. The participants were also found to primarily hail from middle- and upper middle-class families, and their academic and professional success was driven by parents who had encouraged their children to succeed and/or instilled this idea at a young age, pointing to the significant role that socioeconomics play in providing a solid foundation for the upbringing and personal develop- ment of a highly-educated punk rock musician.
Third, the present study’s findings further advance the notion that current punk rock norms and expectations are anywhere from slightly to vastly different than those prevalent in the genre’s initial phases, over 30 years ago. The acceptability of higher education and a professional lifestyle in the punk scene appears to be much greater now than it did during punk’s infancy. This insight not only updates sociological research on punk rock from prior decades, it reflects the idea that punk rock is a dynamic and constantly evolving musical genre.’
84 PUNKADEMICS
Fourth, the findings demonstrate that, although many in the par- ticipant population have followed similar educational and musical paths, their current engagement in the punk scene, as performers, is highly varied. This latitude of engagement ranges from zero participation to performing punk music as one’s main profession and source of income.
In general, the participants spent less time as punk musicians while involved in their professional pursuits (particularly when compared to their younger punk counterparts) than before entering their profes- sional careers. This was mainly due to additional work, family, and fi- nancial obligations, much of which increased with age. The influence of participants’ punk rock backgrounds is particularly noteworthy. Punk rock influenced such specific aspects as school choices, overall academic success, degree goals, creative occupational tactics, and relations in the workplace. Though such influence sometimes extended into participants’ professional settings, their colleagues were often indifferent, if not out- wardly accepting, of the participants’ prior musical endeavors. Though some participants felt the initial need to divorce themselves from their punk ‘heritage,’ many acknowledged that learning to negotiate a pre- sentation of self was often sufficient to ensure success in both punk and professional roles.
Lastly, similarities of both punk rock and academic realms were dis- cussed. Several parallels were presented, including one participant’s argu- ment that since punk rock is a bona fide art movement, it is creative and therefore requires a degree of intellect for mastery, much like an aca- demic discipline. Punk rock’s advocacy for criticism, social commentary, self-awareness, and questioning of ideas also bear a strong similarity to the practices espoused in academia.
Implications of these findings include a reassessment of the punk rock scene generally, and more specifically, a better understanding of an increasingly popular music genre that has changed (in some ways, drasti- cally) since its inception and has, at times, been misrepresented in mass media. Although some punk rock songs may feature incendiary lyrics and aggressive performances, it is also a genre formulated on critical thinking and therefore able to be tethered to intellectual pursuits including higher academia. The findings also suggest that punk rock musicians can be am- bitious, goal-driven, productive, responsible, academically elite, and still seamlessly integrate into mainstream society, all without having to shed the values cultivated by and through their involvement in punk music and culture. Other implications include the idea that these multifaceted professionals can be accepted on either end of the balance, and can also be highly valued in two seemingly disparate realms.
PUNK ROCK DOCS 85
CONCLUSION Though moldy and used in boundless contexts, the time worn adage, “You cant judge a book by its cover” once again rings true with punk rock musicians, particularly with the subset of highly educated musicians investigated in this study. Though some perform with hurried tempos, inciting mosh pits at concerts, while others pen deeply moving, mature, emotional, and profound punk anthems, in the end, these musicians are simply part of a blanket musical movement that has inspired them to create, investigate, and independently shape the course of their lives. For the study’s participants, they — as well as the remainder of the limited, qualified population of those unable to participate or be located — are an enigma or anomaly to some, a special population to others, and just an educator, doctor, attorney, researcher, vocalist, drummer, guitarist, or bassist to the rest of the world. They have beaten odds, shattered assump- tions, jumped through the rigorous hoops of academia, been bestowed with the highest educational credentials and, in the end, might still somehow relate to the kid on the street corner with a spiked hairdo and black leather jacket. Joey Ramone, vocalist of punk rock pioneers, the Ramones, once sang the line, “Gonna get my PhD” in the band’s 1977 song, “Teenage Lobotomy.” Ramone never did attain such level of educa- tion before his passing in 2001. But at least his ambitions — like those of our participant population — were definitely couched in the right place.
NOTES
1 “Punk Rock Docs” is excerpted from a Masters thesis completed in Sum- mer 2008, based in grounded theory methodology.
2 Craig O'Hara, The Philosophy of Punk: More Than Noise (Edinburgh: AK Press, 1999), p. 42; Steven Blush, American Hardcore: A Tribal History (Los Angeles: Feral House, 2001), pp. 114, 165, 330-334; Kevin Matt- son, “Did Punk Matter?: Analyzing the Practices of a Youth Subculture During the 1980s,” American Studies, Vol. 42, No. 1 (2001): 70; Sharon M. Hannon, Punks: A Guide to an American Subculture (ABC-CLIO, 2010), pp. 71-84.
3 For examples of older sociological research on punk, see Philip Lamy and Jack Levin, “Punk and Middle-Class Values: A Content Analysis,” Youth & Society, Vol. 17, No. 2 (1985): 157-170; Kathryn Joan Fox, “Real Punks and Pretenders: The Social Organization of a Counterculture,”
Journal of Contemporary Ethnography, Vol. 16, No. 3 (1987): 344-370.
HELEN REDDINGTON
PUNK THEORY MIX TAPE, SIDE A
MICHAEL SICILIANO AND ALAN O'CONNOR
MAXIMUMSOCIALSCIENCE:
AN INTERVIEW/CONVERSATION WITH ALAN O'CONNOR
EDITOR’S INTRODUCTION 'M NOT SURE where I first encountered Alan O’Connor’s writing on punk, but I remember being immediately impressed by the way he balances com- plex ideas, clear prose, and methodological rigor in nuanced analyses of both punk music and culture, as well as the social structures in which they emerge and exist. Unlike most scholars who venture into the fray, O’Connor is extremely knowledgeable about all facets of punk and his respect for his subject matter is evident in his systematic engagement with the bands, music, literature, ideas, ethics, performances, and institutions (record labels, non-profit spaces) that co-constitute what he describes as the “field of punk.” In addition to being an active participant within this field, his research on it stems from extensive fieldwork and expansive in- terviews that provide the basis from which he probes the social, political, and artistic dimensions of punk throughout the whole of North America. At the same time that I was debating how to best incorporate O’Connor’s work into this collection (he was gracious enough to give me options), I had the pleasure of reading a really smart MA thesis from Michael Siciliano, a graduate student at the University of Chicago whom I knew not from academia, but from our shared experience of spending years immersed in the same punk scene back in Pittsburgh, PA. Given the nature of Siciliano’s recent work on independent record labels, his astute attention to the nuances of social theory, and his background as both a musician and volunteer with Pittsburgh’s DIY show space, the Mr. Roboto Project, it seemed like a no-brainer to put these two gentlemen in touch.
92 PUNKADEMICS
A BRIEF COMMENT ON THE INTERVIEW This interview was conducted through email. Because of this chosen medium of exchange the discussion that follows is multi-threaded and, to some degree, non-linear. This is no doubt due to the chosen format (a conversational interview conducted online, over the course of several weeks). I believe that, above all else, this interview shows Alan O’Connor, a punk, attempting to put cultural studies and the social sciences in the service of DIY punk rather than using punk as just another stepping stone in the building of socio-cultural theory. In my opinion, this is an admirable position for O’Connor to take, and one that ultimately fur- thers the project of cultural studies as a socially engaged, interdisciplinary area of scholarly inquiry.
MICHAEL SICILIANO: So lets start with a few questions about your decision to undertake your relatively recent research on the field of punk record labels.’ Clearly its a development of your previous publications on habitus within music scenes, but I think viewed more broadly, I would ask the following: Why study punk in particular? By this I mean, why this particular subculture and not say, the field of hip-hop or electronic music??
ALAN O'CONNOR: Like many academics who write about punk, I grew up with one foot in the punk scene. Friends and roommates in the 1980s were involved in one way or another. There is a good video about this scene in Toronto called Not Dead Yet. I went to a few shows, including one at Larry’s Hideway, which is featured in the video. But I wasn’t fully part of it because I was in grad school and not on welfare. And I was pretty involved in gay politics. I was a member of the collective of The Body Politic, a serious monthly gay news magazine. But I was interested. I bought a few copies of MRR — which led me to the fantastic notion that all punks were socialists — a couple of albums by the Dicks (an inspired guess) which are now worth serious money, and, of course, the Dead Kennedys. I would say that I was a political type grad student. Punk looked pretty interesting but I was always busy.
In the 1990s I had roommates from the older anarcho-punk scene. They had a wonderful 4-year old. Little kids really like the Ramones, I discovered. And in the early 1990s I moved from that house to a much younger punk house where everyone was heavily involved in the 1990s underground emo/ straight edge scenes. Shotmaker and Chokehold were friends.
Somehow Martin from Los Crudos and I ended up writing to each other. We've since tried to figure out how this happened and we think a
MAXIMUMSOCIALSCIENCE 93
mutual friend who did a queer punk zine gave Martin a letter from this queer punk in Toronto. When Los Crudos were in Mexico in the sum- mer of 1994 (just after the Zapatista uprising in Chiapas) I was visiting a friend whom I met through the community radio scene. And I knew about El Chopo, the outdoor rock market on Saturdays in Mexico City, and wanted to go. Someone brought me and I saw posters for a Los Cru- dos show and of course I went. I’ve told that story in print a few times. So the punk collectives in Mexico accepted me (more or less) and I started to spend summers in Mexico upgrading my Spanish at CEPE — a school for foreigners within Mexico's largest university, UNAM — and hanging out with Mexican punk kids. I wrote a handful of pieces about that, mostly because returning to Canada was always a culture shock and | had to write it all down. I guess you might call it participant observation. I found it very hard to find a theme to focus on and I generally starting writing about how different the scenes are in Toronto and Mexico City. I didn’t believe what theorists like Arjun Appadurai and Garcia Canclini were saying about cultural globalization. Of course punk didn’t start in Mexico, but it sure was very Mexican. It was the differences between Mexico City and Toronto that I found so hard personally. That’s why I was writing in the first place...to try to work through those differences. So I didn’t buy the idea of some easy hybrid culture. I thought punk in Mexico very Mexican.
Ms: Building from the previous question, I wonder how your recent book, Punk Record Labels and the Struggle for Autonomy: The Emergence of DIY, fits into the overall trajectory of your research. Your work in cultural studies began with a distinct anthropological emphasis on media ownership in Latin America and from there you began to focus on punk and its articulation with political movements against Neoliberalism. To some, writing a book about “the field of punk” and now your more current research on scenes might seem to be a move away from “serious” research by virtue is its emphasis on music cultures. I wonder then, why, at this point in your career, did you choose to shift away from your previous emphases on subjects of inequality and global- ization toward this focus on the development of the sub-field of punk within the field of cultural production?
AO: These articles were in effect a defense of Bourdieu’s idea of a habitus. But the research was not systematic; it was ethnography. The book on punk record labels came from a desire to do some systematic research. | wanted something that was less a personal essay and more research that other people could check, or verify, or prove wrong. So I started doing
94 PUNKADEMICS
interviews with record labels. I started with four in Spain, I interviewed Martin when he was in Toronto with Limp Wrist, and then a year later on a sabbatical year (but with no research funding) I did a full tour of the USA. I ended up with 61 interviews that I transcribed myself. I did one a day until I got them all done (a few took two days). I even did one on Christmas Day. I started to ask all the questions that Bourdieu asks: what is this field? What are its boundaries? How does it work? What counts as cultural capital? What is the habitus, or family and educational background of the participants? Does this affect how people participate in the field? I would have liked to do 120 interviews, but I just didn’t have the time or money. I had to get some help with the Correspon- dence Analysis, but when the diagrams came back I felt from my detailed knowledge of these [record] labels and the people I interviewed this was a good diagram of the field. Labels that are similar are mostly gathered near each other; labels that are different are mostly far apart. A lot of this had to do with the age of the label. But that is important: which labels survived. I think some of the findings are, statistically not that strong. There is not a very simple relation between social class (measured by father’s occupation) and the kind of label people run. But I think there is a fairly evident pattern.
I feel much happier with this book than the articles, though the ar- ticles had an important argument. I'd be really happy if more people took up this challenge and did more systematic research on the scene. I love books by participants and have a huge collection of them. But I think social science can contribute too.
Ms: Its very interesting that Martin seems to play a crucial role in your expe- rience as a punk and in your book on the subject. He is certainly a key figure in U.S. hardcore in general and the Latino and queer scenes in particular. As a bit of a side note, I live in the Pilsen neighborhood of Chicago. It has been and continues to be a predominantly Mexican-American neighborhood; it was also the site of some of Crudos’s earliest shows (if Im not mistaken, many of the members were from here or nearby in Little Village, or the Back of the Yards). Recently in a discussion on “authenticity,” an urban sociologist asked “Would a punk band from Pilsen be considered ‘authentic?” which suggests that punk does not come from a working class Latino neighborhood.
In a way this implies that punk, however it is objectively produced and consumed, has the reputation of being white, middle-class, and irrelevant to an urban, working class or poor experience. Though youve said that your data did not provide generalizable observations on the subject, I'd like to pose to you the question of how much Bourdieu’ proposition — that aesthetics are
MAXIMUMSOCIALSCIENCE 95
always the cloak of a class-based ideology — would hold in the field of punk? Or in popular culture ,generally? Can a fan of Shotmaker ever truly enjoy Warzone?
AO: I think if you look at books (mostly not written by academics) on punk in the 1980s that Hebdige’s model [in Subculture] just doesn’t work. There isn’t a single subculture: it splits into all kinds of subscenes such as anarcho-punk, youth anthems, etc. Its different in London and Belfast, not to mention San Francisco and Washington DC. It quickly spreads to many countries mainly through TV coverage of bands like the Sex Pistols, often dies down but then starts up again as a genuinely local scene. I gradually came to realize that Bourdieu’s concept of a field works much better than the concept of subculture. A field has boundaries, but they are usually contested. What is punk and what is heavy metal? Is an experimental college band punk? A field is a space where different pos- sibilities exist: anarcho-punk, emo, straightedge, etc. You can participate in a field in different ways: in a band, doing a zine, doing a record label or distro, as a photographer, etc. Fields change. And the concept of field gets away from the researcher coming up with an arbitrary definition of punk (for the purposes of this study punk is defined as...) when that is actually one of the key issues and conflicts in the scene itself. Emo is not punk in Mexico. You call yourself punk? Hey, you go to grad school!
I don’t agree with your summary of Bourdieu. I don’t think he explains style or aesthetics by social class. It’s not that simple. For a start, Bourdieu sees class as a social field: there are many possible positions. It’s not just a matter of the working class or the middle class. And second, one’s class habitus is a resource for entering different fields such as law school, car sales or punk. It doesn’t determine choices. People still, in some ways, make decisions. For example: to drop out of college and go on tour with your band to Japan. It’s not a simple cause and effect. That’s why you need to interview as many people as possible and why you need a statistical tool like Correspondence Analysis. You can't map the complexities just by in- terviewing 14 people (at most you might find some differences by gender) or doing ethnography without asking systematic questions.
Ms: I think the first part of your response leads quite neatly into another set of questions I have for you that concern the familiar narrative of punk as cultural resistance, as well as cultural studies and the sociology of culture. So, as you stated earlier, it is very important to take into account the writings of participants regarding their experiences of their social situation. That being the case, essays, histories, and memoirs regarding punk culture are, of course,
96 PUNKADEMICS
important. Viewing these products (zines, books, records, etc) and the social processes by which they are produced through the lens of cultural studies, or sociology, of course allows one to discuss punk in terms of its place within the broader context of contemporary society. In terms of your work, and the work of many in cultural studies who write about punk, there is a tendency to- wards partisanship. In a sense, each social scientific text about punk becomes part of the narrative of punk and, as Im sure youre well aware, quite a bit of the work on punk inherits the preoccupations of the Birmingham school with resistance to cultural hegemony.
You, on the other hand, seem to be moving away from this interpretation of subcultures. Do you think that these previous interpretations of subculture carry any validity?
AO: I started to question the concept of subculture mostly from my own experiences in the 1990s of the scenes in Ontario, Quebec and the American Midwest. Certainly Hebdige’s argument in his classic book, Subculture, now seems very dated. Hebdige argues that punk (he seems to mean London about 1976) draws on the postwar period in Britain. Punk is a very odd subculture in the sense that its core style or meaning is actually a refusal of any fixed style or intention. Maybe this fits a very small group of people around the Sex Pistols in 1976. But then Hebdige says that punk has a half-life of about a year before it is recuperated as meaningful, as fashion, deviance, or just good fun.
I really didn’t like the idea of post-subcultures when it emerged a few years ago. I thought it was a mistake. I don’t think the literature on subcultures is very helpful, especially when people start writing about the punk subculture. Anyone who has hung around the scene for any time quickly realizes that there is not one set of meanings. I can remember huge arguments with mostly apolitical people in bands and promoters and what was at stake was they hated my radical politics. There is not a fixed meaning of punk. It is a field in which there are quite contested positions. People have personal and emotional investments in these posi- tions; we've all seen and experienced this.
Ms: Okay, building on that, how do you feel about the issue of partisanship or actively celebrating and enjoying the object of your social-scientific inves- tigation? What problems, personal or professional, has this created for you? More generally, what issues does it pose to researchers?
AO: I love reading books on punk by participants. I have a huge collection of them. But I do want to step outside all the fights and
MAXIMUMSOCIALSCIENCE 97
disagreements in the scene and try to “objectify” it for participants. I think this is the best contribution social science can make. I will never know your local scene as well as you do, but I can help move the scene beyond the debates that go in endless circles. For example, I tried to put together an international research team to look at punk jobs. We were going to each interview about 50 people about their employment history. What jobs do punks get? Do we work in record stores? Used clothing? Stocking shelves at Whole Foods? Are we lawyers? I suspect there are a lot of ex-punk teachers. You know, there is a compilation of punk bands that have teachers in them called Critical Pedagogy: A Compilation of Teachers in Punk Bands which has seventeen bands that include teachers such as Jos from Seein Red and Dave Dictor from M.D.C.4 But we don’t usually ask systematic questions such as, who are the punk photographers? What explains the different styles of doing a record label? Why are so many punks in the USA college dropouts? I wanted my book on record labels to be read by the scene. I tried to make it readable. But it’s different from most books on labels; it’s not promotion or celebration. It tries to intervene in the debates about “major labels” with some detailed research. The book was intended to help people in the scene talk about the issues in a more informed way. That, I think is the role of an academic punk: one foot in the scene and one foot outside.
Ms: To digress a bit for the purpose of clarification, I did not mean to imply that Bourdieu views the relationship between aesthetic preference (or aes- thetic choices on the part of the band or artists) and social class to be deter- ministic. I believe his philosophical resistance to predictive statistical models illustrates that quite clearly. However I do feel that one need only take a glance at Distinction or Rules of Art to get the sense that the struggles over le- gitimate practice and over what might legitimately be called “culture” within the cultural field (of which punk is a subfield) are often linked to social position (i.e. the multi-faceted, spatial conception of class determined by pos- session of various forms of capital).’ The dominant fractions of the dominant class have a vested interest in maintaining and reproducing their conception of legitimate culture and in a variety of circumstance, both in France and the U.S., the boundary between legitimate culture (institutionalized “high art’) and popular arts. This is why, to me, the boundary making in terms of aesthetic and economic practice that you've described continues to fascinate me, especially in the field of popular music production. Here there appears to be so little to be gained in terms of actual capital, yet so much at stake in the symbolic. With so little to gain, I wonder why it is that the struggle in a scene
98 PUNKADEMICS
is often over maintaining ownership over a cultural form that matters so little in terms of getting a job or succeeding in the “real world”?
I think that, theoretically, the conceptual device of the field is incredibly useful in approaching punk in the same way that it has been useful in ap- proaching jazz, journalism, and variety of other social phenomena.® It allows for the diverse and localized articulations of widespread cultural forms in a way that subculture, at least in the Hebdige sense, does not; while it also, as you so astutely pointed out, accounts for the cross-fertilization between scenes via various forms of media (zines, TV, blogs, etc) in a way that Straw’ con- cept of the “scene” does not.’ In a way, it prevents you, and potentially other researchers, from committing the symbolic violence of excluding certain frac- tions of punk from the narrative that academia has been creating for punk over the past 35 years. In fact, it’s only relatively recently that academics seem to have moved away from the notion that music scenes or genres have strict, rigid, and relatively unchanging boundaries and formal definitions, yet this is something that any participant (punk or otherwise) in a music scene knows all too well. Thats an incredibly difficult idea to convey to both academics and punks alike and you manage to do so very well. That said, your book has been criticized by at least one zine (Razorcake) for having a conception of DIY that “too closely follows the MRR axis” and often leaves out the im- portance of other zines and intermediaries involved in contextualizing and relaying information on music scenes to punks.®
I know that youve responded to criticism on the book within academic circles (in 2010), but what do you make of this criticism from the punk scene itself? Have the labels that participated responded in any way? As you stated before, a zine such as MRR is undeniably left leaning and many of its most vocal writers seem to possess at least some college education. Whose conception of punk benefits from excluding other forms of punk practice from this zine and other similar heavyweights of punk publishing and taste making?
AO: I like your wonderful paragraph on the usefulness of the concept of the field. It drives me nuts to see grad students using terms such as the punk subculture, when they as participants in the scene (most of them) know all the differences in music, style, politics, etc. I was really disap- pointed that MRR never reviewed the book. They were sent a review copy but nothing happened. There was a review in Razorcake that mostly complained that other zines such as theirs also contribute to the scene and should have been given more weight. Fair enough. What they don’t realize is that it is almost impossible to get Razorcake in Canada and I only ever saw copies when I traveled in the USA. There was also an on- line review that had the usual punk skepticism about academic writing,
MAXIMUMSOCIALSCIENCE 99
but grudgingly admitted my book might be okay. Actually, this person offered to rewrite his review (in a more positive tone) for MRR but they wouldn't accept it because he might just be my friend and they want neutral objective reviewers. Fair enough.
My book is obviously grounded in the debates in MRR about major labels, and before that about big bands insisting on large guarantees. | hoped to use what systematic research I could do, and the concept of a field (which really is just a sophisticated way of saying a scene with many possible positions in it) to contribute to a debate that usually just goes around in circles. “Who cares if Green Day is on a major? They're cool. And anyway they come from working class families and need the money.’ If you look you'll see that I am quite angry about Green Day. But if you read the book carefully there are also many people who were associated with MRR who have sold out. I wonder if I fell between the cracks because it is just too painful to look at what happened with some of the old crowd.
You'll have picked up on the fact that I think of myself as having one foot in the scene and the other in academia. Maybe that’s a bit different from Bourdieu who, until about 1995, very much wanted to be a so- cial scientist and not an activist. He saw too much thoughtless political posing. But I tried to intervene in the ‘Major Labels’ debate, really as a continuation of the fights we had over this at Who's Emma [DIY info- shop/record store] in Toronto in the 1990s.’ I do have a commitment and I’m a bit different from Bourdieu about that. But I also want to use his tools to “objectify” the scene, to hold up an objective mirror to it so maybe people will think differently about the issues. I also wanted to add to the ongoing debate in the punk scene about who “we” are (building on some data in HeartattaCk readers’ surveys). Obviously I’m looking at older people who stuck around because they had a commitment to punk, but also a role in bands, doing zines, doing distros and labels. So who is this “we”? You can look at the data (including raw info at the back of the book) and see that while there is some diversity, “we” are mainly middle class college dropouts. A few, like me, didn’t quite drop out.
I really do believe, with Bourdieu, that social science has to be a col- lective enterprise. Most of the work I value in cultural studies also has this quality. In studying punk record labels as a field ’m obviously build- ing on work by Bourdieu and others. I would really love it if other people would join in. I think my findings are interesting but tentative. The work I am doing now with Ian McLachlan and our research team on the un- derground arts scene in Peterborough, Ontario (where Trent University is located) is obviously related. We're asking questions about how the
100 PUNKADEMICS
non-commercial theatre and arts scene works in a small city of 60,000 to 70,000 people, located about two hours from a large city such as To- ronto. This scene also makes a space for hardcore punk shows. We want to understand the dynamics of this scene; in a small city people move between theatre, art and music. Everyone goes to everyone else’s events. In a small city you have to. What we're interested in is how Peterborough may be a refuge that makes non-commercial culture (what Bourdieu calls “restricted production”) possible. The rent is cheaper. There is more so- cial support for opting out of legitimate careers. There is a really nice feel about this city. But we are also asking questions about the habitus of everyone involved. Actually, this has been a bit of a struggle in the research team because postmodern theory has done a lot of damage to the idea of social science. But we are now asking the questions about parents’ occupations and education, and the interviewee’s own education and work experience.
What I think I found in the punk record labels research seems to go against what many Marxist researchers would predict. Because, I found that really alternative labels tend to be run by middle class dropouts — literally dropouts, from college. And there is a tendency for working- class kids (especially an older generation) to treat their labels in a more business-like manner. But then the question that Bourdieu poses (and he always annoys cultural studies people because the question is also meant for them) is how far can you trust middle class dropouts? Or to put it in a more positive way, what support does the hardcore punk scene provide to encourage these dropouts to refuse the temptations of major success (what Bourdieu calls “large-scale production”)? This needs more thought and work. My book is quite angry about people who betrayed their youthful ideals, but a lot of other people don’t [betray them]. Dis- chord Records is the heroic example, though they took their own deci- sions rather than following some template for DIY. The question then for all the middle class dropouts who make excuses for what is in effect unethical behavior is, if Dischord can do it, why can’t you?
MS: Id like to move on to two concluding questions, but first, as this is both an interview and a discussion, I'd like to offer some thoughts on your previous statements. As you said, your book is obviously grounded in the de- bates that arise internally within punk (specifically in zines such as MRR). While those debates about major labels are, for the most part, simply discur- sive, they do cause material problems for individuals and companies that seek to bridge this gap between the punk field and the field of music production dominated by multinational media conglomerates. That idea, essentially, was the driving idea behind my own, primarily ethnographic research, on ‘indie
MAXIMUMSOCIALSCIENCE 101 labels (some of whom actually fall within the bounds of punk as delineated
in your work).
Your brief description of your current work strikes me as immediately understandable based on my experience as a musician in both Pittsburgh and Chicago. In Pittsburgh the scene is a bit closer to how you describe Pe- terborough. Noise musicians play with indie rock bands, mash-up DJ Girl Talk used to play with hardcore bands, and everyone watches the football and hockey together. I've also felt that, musically, the bands there were a bit more out there’ in terms of style due to the intersection of these social networks and the fact that the idea of “hitting it big” was generally not part of the creative process. Since arriving in Chicago and playing a decidedly artier form of punk (noise rock a la Amphetamine Reptile Records, essentially), the first question when discussing a band is often ‘are you doing a record and if so, who is putting that out?” A certain emphasis is on making the numbers and creating hype and thats because in a bigger town that is